As used in this chapter, the following terms shall have the
meanings indicated:
RESPONSIBLE PARTY
The record owner of the property shall be the responsible
party for the payment of the transportation utility fee.
The Town of Buchanan elects not to be subject to the administrative
review provisions contained within Ch. 68, Wis. Stats., and establishes
the following as a complete and final review procedure:
A. As a condition precedent to challenging the transportation utility
fee, the charge, if due, must be timely paid in full under protest
to the Town. An appeal can be undertaken only by filing a written
appeal with the Town Clerk. The written appeal shall specify all grounds
for challenge to the amount of the charge and shall state the amount
of charge that the appellant considers to be appropriate. Failure
to timely and properly appeal shall deprive the Town Administrator
and/or Town Board of jurisdiction to hear the appeal.
B. Procedure for appeal. Any responsible party may dispute the amount
of the fee, or dispute any determination made by or on behalf of the
Town pursuant to and by the authority of this chapter. Such petitions
shall be requested in writing and filed with the Town Clerk within
30 days of the date of the property tax bill containing the disputed
transportation utility fee. The appeal must specify the basis for
the appeal and include a traffic study prepared by a traffic engineer
registered in the State of Wisconsin, and shall be limited to the
facts relating to the developed property improvements and area, trip-generation
rates, category of use and other factors material to the calculation
of the transportation utility fee. Failure to timely and properly
appeal shall deprive the Town Board and Circuit Court in certiorari
of jurisdiction to hear the appeal.
(1) Town administrator/classification of property or calculation of fee.
The Town Administrator shall make determinations regarding adjustments
and shall hear and decide appeals where it is alleged that there is
an error in any order, decision or determination made pertaining to
the classification of the property or calculation of the transportation
utility fee. Reclassifications and appeals on the basis of alleged
errors in the determination of the fee as applied to a specific parcel
should be filed with a traffic study that, at a minimum, should be
conducted on a weekday and weekend day during the length of the day.
If the trip-generation rate is within 5% more or less, no adjustment
in the transportation utility fee shall be made because this is within
the expected margins for day-to-day variations. A downward adjustment
in the transportation utility fee shall be made by the Town Administrator
if the traffic count results in a trip-generation rate less than 95%
of the assigned trip-generation rate; however, no adjustment will
be made below the minimum paid by a single-family residence. An upward
adjustment in the transportation utility fee shall be made by the
Town Administrator if the traffic count results in a trip-generation
rate more than 105% of the assigned trip-generation rate. Any adjustment
shall take effect in the year following completion of the traffic
count and be reported in writing to the Town Administrator and Town
Board by the Town Administrator. Once a determination has been made
on a reclassification and/or fee, no additional request may be filed
for the same parcel unless there has been a significant change from
the prior determination. The decision of the Town Administrator is
final except if the property owner appeals the decision to the Town
Board by filing a written appeal with the Town Clerk no later than
30 calendar days after the date of mailing the decision of the Town
Administrator.
(2) Town Board. The Town Board shall hear and decide appeals made on any basis other than an alleged error in the determination of the classification of the property or calculation of the transportation utility fee and shall hear appeals from determinations made by the Town Administrator under Subsection
B(1) above.
(3) An appeal may be taken within 30 days of any of the following events:
(a)
The establishment of the transportation utility fee by resolution
of the Town Board each year; and
(b)
The determination of the Town Administrator as provided in Subsection
B(1) above; and
(c)
Splitting, combining, or other substantial change in the size,
zoning, or use of a parcel.
(4) In considering an appeal, the Town Board shall determine whether
the transportation utility fee is fair and reasonable and, in the
event the appeal is granted, whether or not a refund is due the appellant
and the amount of the refund. The Board shall conduct a formal or
informal hearing at such time and place as designated in a hearing
notice to the appellant, providing at least five business days'
notice to the appellant. The Board shall obtain sufficient facts upon
which to make a determination, and the decision shall be based upon
the evidence presented. The Board shall notify the appellant in writing
of the determination by first class mail addressed to the individual
and at the address listed within the appeal.
(5) The decision of the Town Board is final except if the property owner
appeals the decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. Such appeal
shall be filed no later than 30 calendar days after the date of mailing
the decision of the Board. Such appeal shall be by writ of certiorari,
and the reviewing court shall be limited solely to the record created
before the Board.
The Town Board may, by resolution, exempt any class of user
when it determines that the public interest deems it necessary and
that the contribution to street use by said class is insignificant.
Exceptions may be determined annually through Board action by resolution.
In the event any section, subsection, clause, phrase or portion
of this chapter is for any reason held illegal, invalid or unconstitutional
by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed
a separate, distinct and independent provision, and such holding shall
not affect the validity of the remainder of this chapter. It is the
legislative intent of the Town Board that this chapter would have
been adopted if such illegal provision had not been included or any
illegal application had not been made.