The purpose of this chapter is to provide the City with nuisance abatement procedures that may be pursued to prevent, discourage, abate, or otherwise address any code violations pursuant to Government Code Section 38771 et seq. and all other enforcement options granted to the City.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
The provisions of this chapter shall be applicable to any nuisance defined as a public nuisance by this code or State law. (See CMC § 1.08.040.)
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A. 
The enforcement officer and administrative services director shall log all expenses relating to a code enforcement or nuisance abatement proceeding so the City can recoup these costs in accordance with this section and CMC § 1.08.060.
Costs of abatement shall begin to run from the date the notice of violation and order to abate is first issued, except in cases of summary abatement, in which case costs of abatement shall begin to run from the date the enforcement officer became aware of the nuisance requiring emergency abatement.
B. 
Enforcement costs shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
1. 
Administrative and regulatory costs, which shall include without limitation: (a) any time spent by a City employee or contractor for code enforcement activities related to the code violation, such as inspections and re-inspections, compliance re-inspections, abatement actions, police services, administration, bookkeeping and accounting, legal services, supervision, preparing for and attending hearings; and (b) other costs related to the enforcement such as costs of abatement, notices, and court costs. Costs based on time spent by City employees or contractors shall include salary, benefits, and overhead;
2. 
Late payment charges, which shall include without limitation interest equivalent to the rate permitted by Code of Civil Procedure Section 685.010, as amended, computed from the date the responsible person was first notified of the amount due through the date of payment;
3. 
Collection costs, which shall include without limitation costs incurred in securing payment of any delinquent amount owed to the City, including any costs incurred by the City under CMC § 1.12.160; and
4. 
Attorneys' fees in administrative or judicial proceedings, which shall include without limitation reasonable attorneys' fees incurred for an abatement action and related proceedings where the City elects, at the initiation of that individual action or proceeding, to seek recovery of its attorneys' fees. If the City elects to seek recovery of its attorneys' fees, attorneys' fees may be recovered by the prevailing party in said action or proceeding.
C. 
Recovery of Costs. If a responsible person fails to make payment to the City of any amount owed in accordance with this section, the City may collect the amount owed in any one or more of the following ways:
1. 
Referring the matter to a collection agency.
2. 
Initiating a civil action to collect the debt.
3. 
Where the violation involved real property, making the debt a lien or special assessment against the property in accordance with CMC § 1.12.160.
4. 
Any other manner provided by law for the collection of debts.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A. 
Enforcement officers are authorized to enter upon and inspect any property or premises within the City to ascertain whether the ordinances of the City are being obeyed, including any examinations and surveys as may be necessary in the performance of their enforcement duties. Inspections conducted under this section may include the taking of photographs, samples, or physical evidence.
B. 
Inspections conducted under this section shall be performed reasonably and in accordance with law, including the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution and the related protections of the California Constitution.
C. 
The enforcement officer shall present identification, state the purpose of the inspection, and request permission from the owner or responsible person to enter the property or premises. The enforcement officer shall document permission to enter by securing a signed permission from the owner or occupant. If an owner or occupant of property or his/her agent refuses consent to entry and inspection, an enforcement officer may seek any warrant deemed necessary by the City Attorney.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A. 
When an enforcement officer charged with the enforcement of any provision of this chapter determines that a nuisance exists, the enforcement officer shall notify the responsible person(s) of the existence of the condition(s) on the premises and order them to abate the nuisance. This notice must be served in conformance with CMC § 1.12.090. If the nuisance to be abated requires demolition of a building, grading to the property, or other substantial alterations to real property, the enforcement officer shall obtain a preliminary or survey title report to identify all owners of record, holders of mortgages, deeds of trust, or other liens and encumbrances of record. If additional responsible persons are identified through the preliminary title report, the enforcement officer shall serve each such person with a copy of the notice of violation and order to abate.
B. 
The notice of violation and order to abate shall contain the following information:
1. 
The names and addresses of the owner and any other responsible person(s) in violation of this chapter and the street address, legal description (including Assessor's parcel number) or other description of the premises sufficient to identify the location of the violation.
2. 
A list of the specific code section(s) that have been violated by the responsible person and a statement specifying that the enforcement officer has determined that the violation(s) constitute a nuisance.
3. 
A statement of the action required to be taken to cure the violation as determined by the enforcement officer and a definite time frame for taking that action. This time frame shall be for a reasonable period of time based on the relevant circumstances, which may include the work and time required to correct the violation. The enforcement officer shall have the sole discretion in determining the time frame for taking action to correct the violation.
a. 
If the enforcement officer determines that a building, structure, or property must be repaired, the notice and order shall require that all required permits be secured and the work physically commenced within such time as the enforcement officer determines is reasonable under the circumstances.
b. 
If the enforcement officer determines the building, structure, or property must be vacated, the notice and order shall require the building or structure vacated within a reasonable time as determined by the enforcement officer.
c. 
If the enforcement officer determines the building, structure, or property must be demolished, the notice and order shall require that the building be vacated within such time as the enforcement officer determines is reasonable (not to exceed 60 days from the date of the notice and order), all required permits be secured and the demolition be completed within such time as the enforcement officer determines is reasonable under the circumstances.
4. 
A statement explaining the City's power to abate the nuisance should the responsible person fail to do so in the time allotted by the notice and order.
5. 
The City's intent to seek recovery of enforcement costs, and if applicable, all attorneys' fees.
6. 
The name and phone number of a contact person at the City should the recipient desire to speak with an appropriate City representative.
7. 
A statement advising that (a) any person having any record title or legal interest in the property to be abated may appeal the enforcement officer's order to the Council, provided the appeal is made in writing as provided in this code and filed with the enforcement officer within the time specified under CMC § 1.12.070(B); and (b) failure to appeal within the time and manner provided will constitute: (i) a waiver of all rights to an administrative hearing for determination of the matter, and (ii) a failure to exhaust administrative remedies.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011; Ord. 737 § 2, 2018)
A. 
Form of Appeal. A person appealing an enforcement officer's notice of violation and order to abate shall do so by filing with the enforcement officer a written appeal containing the following information:
1. 
A caption reading: "Appeal of . . . . . . . . ," giving the names of all responsible persons participating in the appeal.
2. 
A brief statement setting forth the appellant's legal interest in the property involved in the notice and order.
3. 
A brief statement in ordinary and concise language of the specific order or action protested, together with any material facts claimed to support the contentions of the appellant.
4. 
A brief statement in ordinary and concise language of the relief sought and the reasons why it is claimed the protested order or action should be reversed, modified, or otherwise set aside.
5. 
The signatures of all parties named as appellants and their official mailing addresses.
6. 
The verification (by declaration under penalty of perjury) of at least one appellant as to the truth of the matters stated in the appeal.
B. 
Time to Appeal. Any appeal of the notice of violation and order to abate issued by the enforcement officer must be filed within 15 days from the date of service of such order.
C. 
Processing of Appeal. Upon receipt of any appeal filed pursuant to this section, the enforcement officer shall present it at the next regular or special meeting of the Council.
D. 
Scheduling and Noticing Appeal for Hearing. As soon as practicable after receiving the written appeal, the Council shall fix a date, time and place for hearing the appeal. Such date shall not be less than 10 days nor more than 60 days from the date the appeal is presented to the Council by the enforcement officer. The City Clerk shall notify the appellant of the time and place of the hearing at least 10 days before the date of the hearing by causing a copy of the notice to be served on each appellant in conformance with CMC § 1.12.080.
E. 
Effect of Failure to Appeal. Failure of any person to file a timely appeal in accordance with this section shall constitute a waiver of the right to an administrative hearing and a failure to exhaust administrative remedies.
F. 
Scope of Hearing on Appeal. Only those issues specifically raised by the appellant in the written appeal provided under subsection (A) of this section shall be considered at the hearing.
G. 
Staying of Order Under Appeal. Except for emergency abatement proceedings, enforcement of any abatement order shall be stayed during the pendency of a timely appeal therefrom.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A. 
General. In the event a responsible person seeks an appeal of the order to abate, the enforcement officer shall issue the responsible person a written notice to appear at a hearing before the Council for the appeal.
B. 
Form of Notice to Appear. The notice to appear shall be substantially in the following form:
TO: ___________________
YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED that a hearing will be held before the Council of the City of Calistoga on the ______ day of __________, 2___, at City Hall, 1232 Washington Street, Calistoga, California, at the hour of _____ p.m., or as soon thereafter as the matter can be heard, upon the attached notice and order served upon you on ______ day of __________, 2___. You may be present at the hearing. You may be, but need not be, represented by counsel. You may present any relevant evidence and will be given a full opportunity to cross-examine all witnesses testifying against you.
Dated this ____ day of _________, 2___.
_______________________________
City Clerk
C. 
Additional Contents of Notice to Appear. The notice to appear shall also include the following information:
1. 
A copy of the enforcement officer's original order.
2. 
A copy of this chapter.
3. 
A statement notifying the appellant that upon the failure to appear for the hearing, or the failure to correct and abate a condition which is determined to constitute a violation, the Council may order the violation(s) abated and the responsible person(s) to bear the costs of the abatement, including without limitation, all enforcement costs and attorneys' fees incurred by the City.
4. 
If necessary, a modified enforcement order noticing the responsible person of any additional violations discovered on the property.
D. 
Method of Service. Unless otherwise noted, any notice to appear or any other notices required to be given pursuant to this chapter shall be served and/or posted at the property at least 10 days before the date of the hearing in accordance with CMC § 1.12.090.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A. 
Notice shall be served by personal delivery of a copy of the notice to the owner and any other responsible person. If a copy of the notice cannot with reasonable diligence be personally delivered, the notice shall be served by (1) certified first class mail, return receipt requested, and (2) regular mail.
B. 
A copy of the notice shall also be conspicuously posted in front of the property on which the nuisance exists, or if posting on the front of the property is not possible, then the notice may be posted in any other location of the property wherein it will be most likely to give notice to the owner.
C. 
Notices by United States mail may be served on the responsible person(s) at the address as shown on the last equalized assessment roll or the supplemental roll of Napa County, whichever is more current. The enforcement officer may, upon the advice of the City Attorney, also serve notice on a tenant, a mortgagor, or any other person having an interest in the real property. Service shall be effective on the date of mailing.
D. 
The failure of any owner or responsible person to receive the notice shall not affect in any manner the validity of the proceedings taken hereunder.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A. 
Continuances. The City may continue a hearing from time to time, and may request additional information from the enforcement officer or the cited responsible person before issuing a decision.
B. 
Burden of Proof. The enforcement officer shall bear the burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence that a public nuisance exists.
C. 
Failure to Appear. The failure of the cited responsible person to appear at the hearing shall constitute a failure to exhaust his/her administrative remedies.
D. 
At the Hearing. At the hearing, the cited responsible person shall be given the opportunity to testify, call witnesses, and to present evidence concerning the abatement order, including any evidence to show cause why the violation should not be abated at the cost of the cited responsible person.
1. 
Oath or Affirmation. All oral evidence or testimony shall be taken under oath or affirmation. The presiding officer may administer the oath. In a given case where many witnesses are expected to testify, the presiding officer has the discretion to have all prospective witnesses rise and be sworn at the same time at the outset of the proceedings.
2. 
Evidence. The hearing need not be conducted according to technical rules relating to evidence and witnesses. Any relevant evidence shall be admitted if it is the sort of evidence on which responsible persons customarily rely in the conduct of serious affairs, regardless of the existence of any common law or statutory rule which might make improper the admission of such evidence over objection in civil actions. Hearsay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining other evidence but shall not be sufficient in and of itself to support a finding unless it would be admissible over objection in civil actions. Irrelevant and unduly repetitious evidence shall be excluded.
3. 
Witnesses. In a contested proceeding each side shall have these rights: to call and examine witnesses; to introduce exhibits; to cross-examine opposing witnesses on any matter relevant to the issues; to impeach any witness and to rebut the evidence against a party. The Council has the discretionary authority to: limit the number of witnesses to testify for each side where their testimony would be cumulative or repetitive in nature; require each side to appoint one spokesperson for purposes of cross-examination; limit or curtail any abusive, argumentative, repetitive, or otherwise irrelevant cross-examination; and place reasonable time limits on the right to cross-examine and present evidence.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A. 
Decision. After considering the testimony and evidence presented at the hearing, the Council shall issue a resolution approving, modifying, or rescinding the enforcement officer's order. The Council's decision shall identify the responsible person's obligation to pay all enforcement costs (including any amounts owed through the date that all violations are corrected).
B. 
Finality of Decision. The decision of the Council shall be final. Nothing in this section shall in any way preclude or limit any aggrieved party from seeking judicial review after such person has exhausted the administrative remedies provided by this section. However, it shall be conclusively presumed that a person has not exhausted his/her administrative remedies as to any issue which is not raised in the administrative proceedings authorized herein, or if the person failed to appear before the Council.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
The City officer authorized to abate the nuisance shall serve a copy of the resolution upon the responsible person in accordance with the service procedures described in CMC § 1.12.090.
Furthermore, if the Council determines that the abatement of the nuisance is likely to cause a significant depreciation in the value of the property, the Council may order that mortgages and/or beneficiaries under any deeds of trust of record on the property be served with a copy of the resolution in the manner prescribed in this chapter.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
The owner or responsible person may, at his/her own expense, abate the nuisance in the time and manner presented in the order to abate issued by the enforcement officer. If an enforcement officer determines that the nuisance has been properly abated, then proceedings pursuant to this chapter shall be terminated; provided, however, that the City may in its discretion proceed with recovery of such abatement costs as it may have incurred before abatement by the owner. Nothing in this chapter shall relieve any owner or other responsible person of the obligation of obtaining any required permits to do any work incidental to such abatement.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
Where a responsible person fails to abate a nuisance in conformance with an abatement order or a resolution of the Council, the enforcement officer may direct any City employee, contracting agent or other representative to enter upon private property for the purpose of abating the public nuisance. Before entering the property, the enforcement officer shall secure written permission from the responsible person to enter upon the property and abate the nuisance. If the property owner or occupant with right of possession is unwilling to provide such permission, the enforcement officer may pursue any warrant deemed necessary by the City Attorney.
Should it be practicable to sell or salvage any material procured from the aforesaid abatement, it may be sold at private or public sale at the best price obtainable and an itemized account of the proceeds shall be maintained by the authorized City officer. Such proceeds, if any, shall be deposited in a general fund of the City and shall be credited against the cost of abatement.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A. 
Upon completion of an abatement action, the enforcement officer shall prepare and file with the Administrative Services Director a report stating the costs incurred by the City in abating the nuisance. If a responsible person is an owner of real property, the amount owed by the responsible person under this section may be made a lien or special assessment against the real property on which the violation occurred.
B. 
Lien or Special Assessment Procedure.
1. 
The Administrative Services Director shall fix a date, time, and place for the Council to consider the report and any protests or objections to it. The Administrative Services Director shall provide written notice to the property owner and any other responsible person not less than 10 days before the hearing in conformance with CMC § 1.12.090.
2. 
A person whose real property may be subject to a lien or special assessment may file a written protest with the Administrative Services Director and/or may protest orally at the hearing. Each written protest or objection must contain a description of the property at issue and the grounds of the protest or objection.
3. 
At the conclusion of the hearing, the Council shall adopt a resolution confirming, discharging, or modifying the amount of the lien or special assessment.
C. 
Upon a determination of the Council to adopt a lien or special assessment, the Administrative Services Director shall provide notice of the lien or special assessment to the responsible person. For a lien, the notice shall be served as provided in California Government Code Section 38773.1. For a special assessment, the notice shall be served as provided in California Government Code Section 38773.5. The Administrative Services Director shall also record any applicable resolution adopted under this section as a lien or a special assessment in the office of the County Recorder of Napa County.
D. 
Once payment in full is received by the City for the amount of the lien or special assessment set forth in the written order, plus any applicable interest or penalties, the Administrative Services Director shall record a notice of discharge with the office of the County Recorder. The notice of discharge shall cancel the City's lien or special assessment.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A. 
Emergency Abatement Authorized. Notwithstanding any other provision of this code, whenever the City Manager reasonably determines there is a nuisance that poses an imminent or immediate danger of significant harm to persons or property, or so endangers the public health or safety, the City may act immediately and without prior notice or hearing to abate the condition. Any emergency abatement under this section shall be authorized in writing by the City Manager or his/her designee and shall be limited to those actions necessary to eliminate the immediate threat. After the immediate threat is eliminated, the enforcement officer may abate any remaining violations through the formal abatement procedures provided for in this chapter.
B. 
Evidence Gathering. Before commencing an emergency abatement, the enforcement officer shall gather evidence of the nuisance to be abated by taking pictures or otherwise documenting the nuisance requiring emergency abatement. All such evidence gathering must be done in compliance with CMC § 1.12.050.
C. 
Notice. Before commencing an emergency abatement, the enforcement officer shall make reasonable attempts to contact the owner or other responsible person by phone or in person. Written notice of the emergency abatement shall be provided to the owner or other responsible person within 48 hours of the abatement. The written notice shall include the following:
1. 
A statement explaining the City's power to abate the nuisance under this section;
2. 
The information provided for in CMC § 1.12.060(B)(1), (2), (5), and (6);
3. 
A copy of this chapter; and
4. 
The time and method for requesting a post-abatement hearing as provided for in subsection (E) of this section.
D. 
Costs. The City may recover the expense or cost resulting from the emergency abatement from the owner or other responsible person in accordance with CMC § 1.12.040.
E. 
Post-Abatement Hearing. An owner or other responsible person may request a hearing before the Council to determine whether the nuisance should have been summarily abated by filing a written request with the City Manager within 15 days of the service of notice set forth in subsection (C) of this section. Such request must be in substantial conformance with CMC § 1.12.070. Failure to request a hearing within the time allotted shall constitute a failure to exhaust administrative remedies.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
A civil action may be brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the City Attorney, the District Attorney, or Napa County Counsel to abate a public nuisance. Each of said officers shall have concurrent right to bring such action to abate a public nuisance within this City. The City Attorney shall bring such action when directed to do so by the Council.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)
If a public nuisance tax has been declared by judicial decree, after a defendant receives notice of entry of judgment as prescribed by law, and the time within which an appeal may be filed has expired, all procedures of this chapter shall be applicable and shall be followed in the same manner as if a resolution by the Council had been passed declaring a public nuisance to exist.
(Ord. 677 § 2, 2011)