Franklin Township is a large and diverse community consisting of rural, suburban, and more urbanized areas. The Township consists of nearly 47 square miles with a population in 2000 of nearly 51,000. The Township is located in a triangle between three regional population and employment centers: New Brunswick to the east, the Bridgewater-Somerville-Raritan area to the north, and the Princeton corridor to the south. As shown on Map 1, the three redevelopment areas are located in less developed portions of the Township, along its western border. All the sites are located adjacent to the Delaware and Raritan Canal State Park. The canal parallels the east bank of the Millstone River, which forms the western boundary of Franklin Township.
A. The Stavola Area.
(1) The Stavola Area, shown on Map 2, consists of two properties at the corner of Canal Road and Old Georgetown Road. Located five miles from Princeton and directly across the D&R Canal and the Millstone River from the Borough of Rocky Hill, the area is rural and characterized by steep slopes. The area forms part of the designated Rocky Hill and D & R Canal Historic Districts, all of which are listed on the State and National Register of Historic Places. The structures on each of these lots were also found eligible for individual listing on the National Register in a study conducted by A.D. Marble Associates in 2002. The structures on these lots are the last remaining remnants of a historic mill village located on the east side of the Millstone River. Both have been used as rental residences in recent years, but they are currently vacant and boarded up.
(2) The structure on Block 8, Lot 1 was constructed in the early 1700s, is representative of 18th century Dutch architecture, and was associated with prominent landowning families in the area. Some of the walls of the structure on Block 9, Lot 1 were constructed possibly as early as the late 18th century, though the structure has been largely rebuilt since that time. The structure served as a saloon for mill workers and canal travelers in the late 19th century.
(3) The redevelopment study found that the area's historic significance is not being properly utilized for the furtherance of the public welfare. The two residential buildings in the area are in a deteriorated condition, rendering them substandard, unsafe and unfit for occupation. The redevelopment study found that because the buildings are unfit for occupation, and because there are no barriers preventing access to the buildings, the location of the subject buildings adjacent to the heavily used Delaware & Raritan Canal Park poses a threat to public safety for anyone entering the buildings. However, the redevelopment study found that the area's location adjacent to the Canal and within designated historic districts provides an important opportunity for historic preservation.
(4) The development of these resources, however, is hindered by difficult topographical and site conditions, and the years of neglect the sites have experienced. Block 8, Lot 1 is an irregularly shaped one-tenth-acre lot occupying the crook created by the sharply angled intersection of Old Georgetown Road and Canal Road. The lot is located in the floodplain and has a steep slope on its east side. Block 9, Lot 1 is four acres in size and is located opposite Old Georgetown Road from Block 8, Lot 1. It consists of two sections, a residential section and an agricultural section. The residential section, which contains the structure described above, is in the floodplain. The larger, agricultural section of the property is located atop a steep slope located just east of the structure and is unused and contains some landscaping. These constraints must be taken into account in the planning of the area. Further, applications for development on lands near the Delaware and Raritan Canal must be submitted to and receive a favorable approval from the Delaware and Raritan Canal Commission.
B. Laurie Rubber Area.
(1) The Laurie Rubber Area consists of several parcels of primarily vacant land in the historic East Millstone community, which consists of a roughly seventy-acre village dating to the early 1800s. The area is in a key location near the center of the historic East Millstone community and adjacent to the D&R Canal State Park (see Map 3). The area is located within both the Delaware and Raritan Canal Historic District and the East Millstone Historic District, both of which are listed on the State and National Register of Historic Places. The historic East Millstone community is also located within one of the Township's historic overlay zoning districts. The Laurie Rubber Area consists of Block 60, Lots 18 through 21 and Block 62, Lots 1, 2, 3, 7, 8 and 10.
(2) The main parcel, Block 60, Lots 18 through 21, is located between the D&R Canal and Market Street. The parcel is the site of a former rubber factory that closed its operations in February 1983. Though they were determined by the Franklin Township Historic Preservation Commission to be historically significant, the factory buildings deteriorated rapidly during the 1980s and were demolished in 1990. The main parcel, Block 60, Lots 18 through 21, is currently a vacant, grassy field, interspersed with young trees. As discussed in the redevelopment study, the property's current bucolic appearance belies its long history as East Millstone's major industrial site. As early as 1846, mattresses were being produced on the site using a husking mill. By 1859, the site was being used as a distillery, converting grain produced in the surrounding rural area into gin and also for the production of bakers' yeast. In 1910, the facility was converted into a rubber-recycling factory which operated until February 1983, just before the ECRA (Environmental Cleanup Responsibility Act) went into effect. An ECRA file (Case No. 84-278) was opened on the facility in 1984 when it appeared the property was going to be sold. The facility was found at the time to contain environmental contamination. However, the ECRA case was closed when the sale fell through. By 1989, significant deterioration had occurred at the facility, which was found by the Township Office of Fire Prevention to pose an imminent health and safety hazard. A demolition permit was issued in 1990, and the site was cleared and cleaned to its current state. While it is believed that some degree of environmental cleanup occurred, the level of contamination that remains is unknown. The unknown level of remaining contamination on the site has likely hindered its redevelopment.
(3) Several parcels between Market and Williams Streets are included in the Laurie Rubber Area as well, because they remain under common ownership with the main parcel. Most of these parcels are also vacant; however, two of the parcels contain a garage and a storage building. Possible environmental contamination may have occurred on this property and has likely contributed to the lack of redevelopment. An environmental study will need to be conducted prior to redevelopment.
(4) It is noted that applications for development on lands adjacent to the Delaware and Raritan Canal must be submitted to and receive a favorable approval from the Delaware and Raritan Canal Commission. The Commission's requirements pose a substantial impediment to new construction in the area between Market Street and the canal and limit the amount of new construction that could take place elsewhere in the area.
C. Onka Bus-Franklin Inn Area.
(1) The Onka Bus-Franklin Inn Area, at 4.4 acres in size, is located on the north side of Amwell Road, across from the heart of the historic East Millstone community and within the Delaware and Raritan Canal Historic District (see Map 3). The area is located adjacent to the D&R Canal Park and is across Amwell Road from a small park and several historic buildings currently used for retail and offices. The Onka Bus-Franklin Inn Area consists of Block 512, Lot 4.
(2) The area contains a historic inn adjacent to the canal. The inn has been documented on the Historic American Building Survey (Reference No. NJ-648). The two-story frame inn was originally constructed as a farmhouse in 1752 but was expanded into an inn during the 19th century. The inn closed during the Prohibition era, and the property has been under its current ownership since the mid-20th century. Since the 1960s, the inn has housed a canoe rental service, an antique store, and is currently leased to the Blackwells Mills Canal House Association. A small used bookstore is operated in the building on an intermittent basis. The exterior of the inn appears to be in fair condition and has recently been scraped, primed and repainted. However, damage to the interior has been recorded.
(3) The area includes a complex of much newer buildings, located to the east of the inn, that had recently served as a bus depot but now appears to be used primarily for vehicular maintenance and repair. There is a gravel parking area between these newer buildings and the historic inn, as well as a parking area in front of the newer buildings. A large gravel yard on the east side of the property and visible from the Village of East Millstone is used for vehicle storage and additional parking. The property formerly included a gas station and contained six underground oil storage tanks, which were removed in 1991. An assessment of environmental contamination on the site would be needed if the site were to be redeveloped.
(4) The redevelopment study found that the presence of the bus depot use is deleterious to the surrounding community and the historic inn, that its presence hinders the rehabilitation of the Franklin Inn and is harmful to the adjacent East Millstone historic village, and that the negative visual impacts from the use are visible from both the Inn and the East Millstone community.
(5) Applications for development on lands adjacent to the Canal must be submitted to and receive a favorable approval from the Delaware and Raritan Canal Commission. The Commission's requirements significantly limit the amount of new or additional development that could take place in the area.