[Adopted 1996 ATM by Art. 33; amended 2005 ATM by Art. 22; 4-27-2015 ATM by Art. 18 (Art. 73 of the General Bylaws)]
The purpose of this bylaw is to ensure that streets and roads which have been designated as scenic roads are not altered, repaired, reconstructed, or paved in such a manner as to involve or include the cutting or removal of trees, or the tearing down or destruction of stone walls, except with the prior written consent of the Planning Board, and to establish proper procedures, standards and conditions for obtaining approval from the Planning Board and, when appropriate, the Tree Warden.
This bylaw is enacted pursuant to authority vested in the Town by MGL c. 40, §§ 21 and 15C, and c. 87, § 2.
The following streets and roads have been designated by the Town as scenic roads pursuant to MGL c. 40, § 15C (listed by name and date of designation):
Acorn Street (1976)
Bow Street (1977)
Canal Street (1976)
Canoe Tree Street (1977)
Church Street (1974)
Cornhill Lane (1977)
Cross Street (1997)
Dog Lane (1977)
Elm Street (1997)
Ferry Street (1974)
Forest Street (1976)
Highland Street (1974)
Marginal Street (1977)
Maryland Street (1997)
New Street (1977)
Old Main Street (1976)
Old Main Street Extension (1976)
Old Mount Skirgo (1977)
Old Ocean Street (1996)
Old Plain Street (1976)
Parsonage Street (1974)
Pine Street (1974)
Pleasant Street (1976)
Prospect Street (1977)
Pudding Hill Lane (1976)
School Street (1974)
South River Street (1974)
Spring Street (1974)
Summer Street (1974)
Union Street (1974)
Webster Street (1976)
Willow Street (1977)
Winslow Cemetery Road (1974)
Winslow Street (1976)
[Amended 10-18-2021 STM by Art. 32]
The Planning Board, the Select Board, the Conservation Commission, or the Historical Commission, or by petition of citizens of the Town (consistent with petition requirements to place an article on the warrant), may propose that a street or way in the Town be designated as a scenic road within the meaning of MGL c. 40, § 15C, other than a street or way with a numbered route or that which is considered to be a state highway.
A. 
In order to be eligible for such a designation, streets or ways must also meet the following minimum criteria:
(1) 
The street or way must be bordered by trees of exceptional quality; and/or
(2) 
The street or way must be bordered by stone walls; and/or
(3) 
The street or way must be bordered by other natural or man-made features of aesthetic or historic value.
B. 
The Planning Board shall hold a public hearing on the petition, after notifying the Select Board, the Tree Warden, the DPW Superintendent, the Conservation Commission and the Historical Commission of the time, date, place and purpose of the hearing, and advertising the time, date, place and purpose of the hearing twice in a newspaper of general circulation in the area, the first advertisement at least 14 days prior to the date of the public hearing and the last publication to occur at least seven days prior to such hearing.
C. 
Based on the information presented at the public hearing, the Planning Board shall make a recommendation to the Town Meeting on the merits of designation of the proposed road as a scenic way. A majority vote of Town Meeting is required for designation. Such designation shall be effective as of the date of Town Meeting action.
In the absence of contrary meaning established through legislation or judicial action pursuant to MGL c. 40, § 15C, these terms contained in that statute shall be construed as follows:
CUTTING OR REMOVAL OF TREES
Shall not be construed to include routine or emergency tree maintenance which removes only permanently diseased or damaged limbs, trunks or roots or whole trees as determined by the Tree Warden, or sound limbs, trunks or roots of a tree with a diameter six inches or larger measured one foot above ground level, that hinder a public way as determined by the Tree Warden.
REPAIR, MAINTENANCE, RECONSTRUCTION OR PAVING WORK
Any work done within the right-of-way by any person or agency, public or private. Construction of new driveways or alterations of existing ones is also included to the extent that such work takes place within the right-of-way.
ROAD RIGHT-OF-WAY
The entire right-of-way including, but not limited to, a vehicular traveled way, plus its necessary appurtenances within the right-of-way, including bridge structures, drainage systems, retaining walls, traffic control devices, pedestrian facilities and the air space above them, but not intersecting streets or driveways. When the boundary of the right-of-way is in issue so that a dispute arises as to whether or not certain trees or stone walls are within the right-of-way, the boundary shall be determined in accordance with MGL c. 86.
STONE WALLS
Shall not be construed to include assemblages of stone involving less than one cubic foot of wall material per linear foot (above the existing grade) nor totaling less than five feet in length.
TEARING DOWN OR DESTRUCTION OF STONE WALLS
Shall not be construed to include temporary removal and replacement within 30 days at the same location with the same materials.
TREES
Any woody plants with a trunk two inches or greater diameter providing visual or noise screen or aesthetic value or having a trunk diameter with a diameter of six inches or larger, one foot above the ground.
A scenic road application shall conform to the following design standards:
A. 
Where stone walls exist, the maximum amount of stone wall to be removed shall be limited to a maximum of 24 feet width.
(1) 
Removed stone shall be used to repair other sections of the wall along the road.
(2) 
No wall shall be cut without construction of tapered ends turning back onto the lot along the drive (see attached drawing).[1]
[1]
Editor's Note: The drawing is on file at the office of the Town Clerk.
B. 
No tree with a trunk exceeding eight inches in diameter four feet above the ground level shall be cut for a driveway unless the curb cut cannot be safely located otherwise; clusters of trees located within six feet of each other with individual trunks of six inches in diameter, one foot above ground level, shall not be cut for a driveway unless the curb cut cannot be safely located otherwise.
C. 
For each tree exceeding six inches in diameter, one foot above ground level, removed, a tree in a species and location suitable to the Planning Board and Tree Warden shall be planted or the amount for the planting of a tree shall be donated to the Tree Fund to be used at the discretion of the Tree Warden.
Any person or organization seeking consent of the Planning Board under MGL c. 40, § 15C (the Scenic Road Act), regarding the cutting or removal of trees or the tearing down or destruction of stone walls, or portions thereof, in connection with the repair, maintenance, reconstruction or paving work on scenic roads, shall submit a written request to the Planning Board by filing such request with the Town Clerk, with a copy to the Tree Warden, together with the following:
A. 
A completed application form.
B. 
A plan showing the location and the nature of the proposed action and a description of the proposed changes to trees and stone walls. Two copies of the plan showing the proposed changes are required.
C. 
A statement of the purpose(s) for the changes.
D. 
Notice of the public hearing, which shall include the size, type and location of the trees(s) and/or stone wall to be cut or removed shall be given by publication in a newspaper of general circulation in the Town of Marshfield once in each of two successive weeks, the last publication of said notice to occur at least seven days before the day of the hearing.
E. 
Any tree(s) proposed to be removed shall be flagged (with red tape) a minimum of 14 days before the day of the hearing.
F. 
Portions of any stone wall to be removed shall be staked and flagged (with red tape) a minimum of 14 days before the day of the hearing.
G. 
Except in the case of Town agencies, a filing fee of $200 shall be paid.
H. 
Photograph(s) of the existing site showing the area to be affected by work on the scenic road in question. All photographs must be signed and dated by the applicant.
I. 
Any further explanatory material useful to adequately inform the Tree Warden and/or Planning Board prior to the public hearing.
[Amended 4-24-2017 ATM by Art. 10]
The Planning Board and Tree Warden shall hold a joint public hearing within 45 days from the date on which notice of submittal is received by the Town Clerk. The decision of the Planning Board shall be filed within 14 days of the close of the public hearing with the Town Clerk. Copies of the decision shall also be sent to the applicant, the Tree Warden, the Building Commissioner, the Conservation Commission, the Historical Commission and those persons who have requested a copy of the decision.
In acting in regard to a scenic road, the Planning Board and Tree Warden shall consider the following:
A. 
Preservation of scenic and aesthetic characteristics;
B. 
Preservation of natural resources and environmental and historical values;
C. 
Public safety, traffic volume and congestion;
D. 
Compensatory actions proposed, such as replacement of trees or walls;
E. 
Financial and other consequences of design revision to avoid or reduce damage to trees or stone walls;
F. 
Other site-specific factors.
Any person violating the provisions of the second paragraph of the Massachusetts Scenic Roads Act (MGL c. 40, § 15C) shall be punished by a fine of $300 per day. For the purpose of this section, fines may be assessed by the Zoning Enforcement Officer and/or a police officer of the Town of Marshfield. Each day during which such a person continues to be in violation of the provisions of said Act shall be considered to be a separate violation for the purpose of the assessment of fines under this bylaw. Violations of the bylaw may be handled by noncriminal disposition in accordance with MGL c, 40, § 21D.