Except as hereinafter provided, this chapter shall not apply to structures or uses lawfully in existence or lawfully begun, or to a building or special permit issued before the first publication of notice of the public hearing on this chapter, but shall apply to any change or substantial extension of such use, to a building or special permit issued after the first notice of said public hearing, to any reconstruction, extension or structural change of such structure, and to any alteration of a structure begun after the first notice of said public hearing to provide for its use for a substantially different purpose or for the same purpose in a substantially different manner or to a substantially greater extent, except where alteration, reconstruction, extension or structural change to a single- or two-family residential structure does not increase the nonconforming nature of said structures.
A. Objectives. The provisions of this section are intended to achieve the following purposes:
(1) Allow nonconforming situations to continue until they are discontinued or abandoned.
[Amended 5-14-2001 ATM by Art. 29]
(2) Encourage change in nonconforming situations towards greater compliance with the provisions of this chapter and to reduce the degree of nonconformity. Where a nonconforming situation is proposed to be changed, to encourage greater conformity with all the provisions of this chapter and the objectives and procedures stated in this chapter.
(3) To allow for the alteration, expansion or extension of a nonconforming use, subject to the issuance of a finding by the Planning Board or Zoning Board of Appeals as specified. Nonconforming uses in residential zones shall be subject to more restrictive standards than those in nonresidential zones.
(4) To permit possible expansion of nonconforming buildings, provided there are no demonstrable adverse impacts on the adjoining properties.
(5) In the event of the involuntary destruction in whole or part of a nonconforming situation, to permit the reconstruction of the nonconforming situation so that the owner, and tenants, if any, are not subjected to substantial economic loss while, at the same time, seeking to achieve greater conformity with the provisions of this chapter and to reduce any adverse impact on the surrounding area.
(6) To permit the treatment of nonconforming situations to be varied by the type of zoning district and the type of nonconformity; i.e., to have a different approach for uses, structures, and parking lots.
B. Applicability.
(1) Nonconforming situations. For the purpose of this chapter, "nonconforming situations" are those uses, buildings, structures, parking lots, parking spaces, loading bays, signs, landscaping and other activities that are now subject to the provisions of this chapter which were lawful before this chapter was adopted, or before amendments to this chapter which are applicable to the situation were adopted, and such situations do not now conform to the provisions of this chapter.
(2) Noncomplying situations. For the purposes of this chapter, "noncomplying situations" are those uses, buildings, structures, lots, parking spaces, loading bays, signs, landscaping and other activities that are subject to the provisions of this chapter which were unlawfully created after this chapter was adopted or after amendments to this chapter which are applicable to those situations were adopted, and are in violation of this chapter and may be called "noncomplying situations."
[Amended 5-14-2001 ATM by Art. 29]
(3) Noncomplying situations six years or older. In accordance with MGL c. 40A, §
7, any structure, or part thereof, which has been improved and used in accordance with the terms of a building permit issued by a duly authorized person may not be the subject of an enforcing action by the Town to compel the removal, alteration or relocation of said structure, or the abandonment, limitation or modification of the use allowed by said permit, unless enforcement action is commenced within six years from the date of the alleged violation of law. Uses and structures in existence for six years or more and which qualify under this section are considered to be nonconforming situations and are entitled to treatment as such, as provided in this section.
(4) Noncomplying structures 10 years or older. In accordance with MGL c. 40A, §
7, any structure, or part thereof, which has not been in compliance with this chapter, or the conditions set forth in any special permit or variance affecting the structure, may not be the subject of an enforcement action by the Town unless enforcement action is commenced within 10 years from the date of the alleged violation of law. Structures in existence for 10 years or more and which qualify under this section are considered to be nonconforming situations and are entitled to treatment as such, provided that any proposed change, alteration or extension will not affect the noncomplying conditions. Any change, alteration or extension of the noncomplying condition shall be subject to the provisions of the chapter and require that form of relief which would otherwise be necessary to allow said change, alteration or expansion.
C. Limitations. A use, building, structure, lot, parking space, loading bay, sign, landscaping or any other activity which is nonconforming, but not noncomplying, may be continued but may not be increased, expanded or altered, except as may be specifically authorized by this section. If such nonconforming situation is abandoned or terminated, as set forth below, it may not be resumed except in compliance with this chapter.
D. Lawfully created situations. A use, building, structure, lot, parking area, loading bay, sign, landscaping or any other activity is considered to be lawfully created with respect to zoning requirements if:
(1) It was in existence on June 16, 1980, when the zoning ordinance was originally adopted; or
(2) Subsequent to June 16, 1980, it was permitted by the zoning ordinance either by right or by special permit and was in existence prior to the effective date of any amendment which rendered it nonconforming.
E. Uses by variance which are not nonconforming. A use, building, structure, lot, parking area, loading bay, sign, landscaping or any other activity which is not otherwise permitted and does not comply with this chapter and exists due to the granting of a variance is not a nonconforming situation, is not entitled to the treatment afforded by this section, and is bound by the conditions of the variance as granted.
F. Once in conformity, or closer to conformity, cannot revert. Once a use, building, structure, lot, parking area, loading bay, sign, landscaping or any other activity which had been nonconforming is brought into conformity with this chapter, it shall not be permitted to revert to nonconformity. Once a use, building, structure, lot, parking area, loading bay, sign, landscaping or any other activity which had been nonconforming is brought closer to conformity with this chapter, i.e., the amount or degree of nonconformity is reduced, it shall not be permitted by right to revert to nonconformity with the provisions of this chapter which is greater than the closest amount or degree of conformity which it has achieved.
[Amended 5-14-2001 ATM by Art. 29]
G. Change in lot that results in noncompliance. No lot upon which there is a building or for which a building permit is in force shall be subdivided or otherwise changed in area or shape, except through public acquisition, so as to result in a violation applicable to either the lot or the building. A lot already nonconforming shall not be changed in area or shape so as to increase the degree of nonconformity with the requirements of this chapter; however, a nonconforming lot may be changed in area or shape in order to move closer to conformity with the requirements of this chapter. Said change shall be allowed by right. No building permit, special permit, certificate of occupancy, or approval of a subdivision plan under the Subdivision Control Law shall be issued with reference to said transferred land until both the lot retained and the newly created lot(s) meet the requirements of this chapter.
H. Nonconformity resulting from public action. If, as a result of public action, a use, building, structure, lot, parking area, loading bay, sign, landscaping or any other activity no longer complies with this chapter, it shall be considered to be nonconforming and entitled to the treatment afforded by this section, provided it was in compliance or lawfully nonconforming at the time of the public acquisition.
I. Discontinuance and abandonment.
(1) A nonconforming use or structure or other nonconforming situation is considered to be discontinued or abandoned whenever:
(a) It is not used for a period of 24 consecutive months; or
(b) It is abandoned (as defined in this chapter).
(2) Discontinuance or abandonment of a part of a nonconforming use, structure or situation shall not normally be considered to be evidence of discontinuance or abandonment of the whole, unless that part which is discontinued or abandoned is the part which causes the nonconformity.
(3) The rights of a nonconforming use, structure, building, lot, parking space, loading bay, sign, landscaping or other situation are not affected by a change in ownership, tenancy or management unless such ownership, tenancy or management is specifically a condition of the issuance of the permit.
J. One- and two-family dwellings.
[Amended 5-14-2001 ATM by Art. 29]
(1) Nonconforming uses. An existing nonconforming one-family or two-family owner-occupied dwelling or structure accessory thereto which is nonconforming with respect to use may be enlarged or extended for use for the same purpose, provided that a finding is issued by the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) that the extension or enlargement is not substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing use.
(2) Nonconforming structures. An existing nonconforming one-family or two-family dwelling or structure accessory thereto which is nonconforming with respect to minimum setbacks may be enlarged or extended in any other direction in compliance with this chapter, or in any other direction without encroaching any further than the original nonconformity, by the issuance of a building permit. That part of an existing nonconforming dwelling which is nonconforming only with respect to a minimum setback and/or density requirements of this chapter may not be enlarged or extended in that setback or requirement, except by a finding issued by the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) that:
(a) The degree of proposed nonconformity is not substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformity, with particular consideration of abutting properties;
(b) The site coverage of the dwelling within the minimum setback is not increased to an extent so as to be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformity, with particular consideration of abutting properties; and
(c) The Board determines that the extension or enlargement is appropriate in scale and mass for the neighborhood, with particular consideration of abutting properties.
K. Other than one- and two-family dwellings.
(1) Nonconforming uses. A nonconforming use may be continued to the same degree and for the same purpose. An existing nonconforming use may be altered, expanded or extended for use for the same purpose or changed for use for a different purpose, provided that a finding is issued by the Planning Board as specified in the following sentence. The Planning Board may grant a finding for alteration, change, expansion or extension of a nonconforming use, provided that the Board determines that the alteration, change, expansion or extension is not substantially more detrimental than the current use.
(2) Nonconforming structures.
(a) An existing nonconforming building, other than a one-family or two-family dwelling, which is nonconforming with respect to minimum setbacks may be enlarged or extended in any other direction in compliance with this chapter by the issuance of a building permit (and other permits as appropriate), provided all other uses, structures, and activities on the lot comply fully with the requirements of this chapter. That part of an existing nonconforming structure which is nonconforming only with respect to a minimum setback and/or density requirements of this chapter may not be enlarged or extended in that setback or requirement, except by a finding issued by the Planning Board that:
[1] The degree of proposed nonconformity is not substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformity, with particular consideration of abutting properties;
[2] The site coverage of the dwelling within that minimum setback is not increased to an extent so as to be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformity, with particular consideration of abutting properties; and
[3] The Board determines that the extension or enlargement is appropriate in scale and mass for the neighborhood, with particular consideration of abutting properties.
(b) An existing nonconforming building, other than a one-family or two-family dwelling, which is nonconforming with respect to dimensional and/or density requirements of this chapter for the district in which said building is located, other than minimum setback, may not be enlarged or extended except by a finding issued by the Planning Board.
L. Nonconforming lots. Any lot which does not comply with the provisions of this chapter with respect to minimum lot area, minimum lot frontage, or minimum lot width or with the requirements then in effect at the time of recording or endorsement, whichever occurs sooner, shall not be subdivided or otherwise changed in area or shape, except through public action, so as to be in violation of the provisions of this chapter. A lot already nonconforming with respect to those provisions may be changed to be made closer in compliance, but once brought closer into compliance, i.e., the amount or degree of nonconformity is reduced, it shall not be permitted to revert to noncompliance which is greater than the closest amount or degree of compliance which it had achieved. A lot which is nonconforming shall not preclude the issuance of permits allowed pursuant to Article
V.
M. Nonconforming off-street parking and loading.
(1) Existing nonconforming parking spaces, loading bays.
(a) Any off-street parking spaces or loading bays in existence on the effective date of this chapter or thereafter established, which serve a building or use, may not be reduced in number or changed in location or design contrary to this chapter's requirements so as to increase the degree of nonconformity with said requirements.
(b) If the use of an existing structure or lot which does not have sufficient parking or loading areas, including a use which has no off-street parking or loading area, is changed to a different type of use for which a different number of parking spaces or loading bays is required as set forth in this chapter, and there is no increase in the net floor area, the following rules shall apply:
[1] If there is a net increase in the number of required parking spaces or loading bays, that net increase shall be provided, which number shall not include any existing parking spaces or loading bays; or
[2] If there is a net decrease in the number of required parking spaces or loading bays, that lesser number shall be the new basis for determining whether, in the future, there is a net increase in the number of parking spaces or loading bays required.
[3] If it is proposed to increase the net floor area of a building, whether by addition to the exterior of the building or by internal reconstruction, and the building does not have sufficient off-street parking or loading area, full compliance with the applicable parking requirements for the entire building shall be a condition of the issuance of a building permit for the construction of the increase of net floor area.
N. Parking and loading requirements for a building destroyed, damaged or demolished. If a building for which sufficient off-street parking or loading area as required under the standards of this chapter is not provided is destroyed, damaged or demolished by the owner, the new building may be reconstructed or replaced if otherwise permitted by this chapter, without providing additional parking spaces or loading bays, provided the new use is the same type of use as the use before the destruction, damage or demolition, or is a type of use that requires the same or fewer parking spaces or loading bays. If parking spaces or loading bays were provided before the destruction, damage, or demolition, at least the same number of spaces or bays shall be provided.
[Amended 5-14-2001 ATM by Art. 29]
O. Repair, reconstruction, continuance. Routine maintenance and repairs are permitted to a nonconforming structure, sign, parking space or loading bay or other nonconforming situation to maintain it in sound condition and presentable appearance.
P. Reconstruction after involuntary destruction (by right). Any nonconforming use, structure, building, sign, parking space or loading bay or other nonconforming situation which is destroyed or damaged by explosion, collapse, fire, storm, natural disaster or other catastrophic event, any of which is beyond the control of the owner, may, within three years from the date of such damage or destruction, be reconstructed to the same extent as the original, provided there is no increase in the site coverage or the gross floor area or the degree of nonconformity and the reconstruction conforms to the current requirements of this chapter to the maximum extent practicable in the opinion of the Building Inspector. In this context, to the maximum extent practicable, the Building Inspector shall consider extreme site conditions, such as steep grades, the presence of ledge or other unsuitable soil conditions, or the shape and configuration of the lot.
[Amended at time of adoption of Code (see Ch. 1, General Provisions, Art. I)]
Q. Reconstruction after destruction (by finding). The Planning Board may grant a finding for the reconstruction of a use, structure, building, sign, parking space or loading bay or other situation allowed by finding, which is destroyed or damaged by explosion, collapse, fire, storm, natural disaster or any other catastrophic event, any of which is beyond the control of the owner or by the proposed voluntary action of the owner, to demolish, in whole or in part, in a manner different from the prior conditions, provided the Board determines that:
(1) The degree of proposed nonconformity is not substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformity, with particular consideration of abutting properties;
(2) The site coverage of the dwelling within that minimum setback is not increased to an extent so as to be substantially more detrimental to the neighborhood than the existing nonconformity, with particular consideration of abutting properties; and the Board determines that the extension or enlargement is appropriate in scale and mass for the neighborhood, with particular consideration of abutting properties; and
(3) The Board determines that the extension or enlargement is appropriate in scale and mass for the neighborhood, with particular consideration of abutting properties.
[Amended 6-24-2002 STM by Art. 2]
R. Vesting of rights during adoption of amendments.
(1) A use, building, structure, lot, sign, parking space or loading bay or other situation which would comply with the provision of this chapter at the time at which a building permit is issued or a special permit is granted, but would not comply with a proposed amendment to this chapter, shall be considered to be nonconforming and may be completed, continued, or maintained, provided the building permit was issued or the special permit was granted before the first publication of notice of public hearing of the proposed amendment, and substantial physical construction or start of operations is begun within 12 months of the issuance of the building permit or the grant of a special permit and is carried through to its completion as continuously and expeditiously as is reasonable. If the construction is not completed within 18 months of the issuance of the building permit or the grant of the special permit, the rights to nonconforming status shall cease and the construction shall comply with this chapter, as amended.
[Amended at time of adoption of Code (see Ch. 1, General Provisions, Art. I)]
(2) The filing of an application for either a building permit or a special permit is not sufficient to vest rights. The building permit must be issued or the special permit must be granted prior to such first publication of notice.
(3) In the event of the filing and subsequent approval of a definitive subdivision plan, an exemption from an amendment to this chapter and a right to be treated under the previously existing provision of this chapter may be vested, as set forth in MGL c. 40A, §
6.
S. Approval not required plans.
(1) In the event of the filing and subsequent endorsement of an "Approval Not Required" plan, referred to in MGL c. 41, §
81P of the Subdivision Control Law (MGL c. 41, §§
81K through
81GG), an exemption from an amendment to this chapter affecting the use of land only and a right to be treated under the previously existing provisions of this chapter may be vested, as set forth in MGL c. 40A, §
6.
(2) In the event that rights have been vested under a previous version of the zoning ordinance, an owner may proceed as if that version of the zoning ordinance applied to his/her property and he/she may use the most current versions of the zoning ordinance, but must use either version of the zoning ordinance fully and cannot select provisions of both versions.