[Amended 3-27-1997 by Ord. No. 97-14]
A. All clearing and soil disturbance activities shall
be limited to that which is necessary to accommodate an activity,
use or structure which is permitted by this chapter;
B. Where practical, all clearing and soil disturbance
activities associated with an activity, use or structure, other than
agriculture, forestry and resource extraction, shall:
(1) Avoid wooded areas, including New Jersey's Record
Trees as published by the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection
in 1991 and periodically updated; and
(2) Revegetate or landscape areas temporarily cleared
or disturbed during development activities.
C. All applications for major development shall contain
a landscaping or revegetation plan which incorporates the elements
set forth in Section D below.
D. In order to conserve water, conserve natural features and reduce pollution from the use of fertilizers, pesticides and other soil supplements, all landscaping or revegetation plans prepared pursuant to Section C above or required pursuant to §
215-16A of Chapter
215 of this Code shall incorporate the following elements:
(1) The limits of clearing shall be identified.
(2) Existing vegetation, including New Jersey's Record
Trees as published by the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection
in 1991 and periodically updated, shall be incorporated into the landscape
design where practical.
(3) Permanent lawn or turf areas shall be limited to those
specifically intended for active human use such as play fields, golf
courses and lawns associated with a residence or other principal nonresidential
use. Existing wooded areas shall not be cleared and converted to lawns
except when directly associated with and adjacent to a proposed structure.
(4) Shrubs and trees authorized by N.J.A.C. 7:50-6.25
shall be used for revegetation or landscaping purposes. Other shrubs
and trees may be used in the following circumstances:
(a)
When the parcel to be developed or its environs
contain a predominance of shrubs and tree species not authorized by
N.J.A.C. 7:50-6.25.
(b)
For limited ornamental purposes around buildings
and other structures.
(c)
When limited use of other shrubs or tree species
is required for proper screening or buffering.
E. Development prohibited in the vicinity of threatened
or endangered plants. No development shall be carried out by any person
in the Pinelands Area unless it is designed to avoid irreversible
adverse impacts on the survival of any local populations or threatened
or endangered plants of the Pinelands designated in N.J.A.C. 7:50-6.27.
[Amended 3-27-1997 by Ord. No. 97-14]
A. Permit required. No forestry in the Pinelands Area
of the Township shall be carried out by any person unless a permit
for such activity has been issued by the Township Zoning Officer.
Notwithstanding this requirement, no such permits shall be required
for the following forestry activities:
(1) Normal and customary forestry practices on residentially
improved parcels of land that are five acres or less in size.
(2) Tree harvesting, provided that no more than one cord
of wood per five acres of land is harvested in any one year and that
no more than five cords of wood are harvested from the entire parcel
in any one year.
(3) Tree planting, provided that the area to be planted
does not exceed five acres in any one year, no soil disturbance occurs
other than that caused by the planting activity and no trees other
than those authorized by N.J.A.C. 7:50-6.25 are to be planted.
(4) Forest stand improvement designed to selectively thin
trees and brush, provided that no clearing or soil disturbance occurs
and that the total land area on the parcel in which the activity occurs
does not exceed five acres in any one year.
(5) Prescribed burning and the clearing and maintaining
of fire breaks.
B. Forestry application requirements. The information in Subsection
B(1) or
B(2) below shall be submitted to the Township Zoning Officer prior to the issuance of any forestry permit:
[Amended 9-22-2011 by Ord. No. 2011-19]
(1) For forestry activities on a parcel of land enrolled in the New Jersey
Forest Stewardship Program, a copy of the approved New Jersey Forest
Stewardship Plan. This document shall serve as evidence of the completion
of an application with the Pinelands Commission as well as evidence
that the activities are consistent with the standards of the Comprehensive
Management Plan. No certificate of filing from the Pinelands Commission
shall be required.
(2) For all other forestry applications:
(a)
The applicant's name and address and his or her interest in
the subject parcel.
(b)
The owner's name and address, if different from the applicant's,
and the owner's signed consent to the filing of the application.
(c)
The description, including block and lot designation and street
address, if any, of the subject parcel.
(d)
A description of all existing uses of the subject parcel.
(e)
A brief written statement generally describing the proposed
forestry operation.
(f)
A USGS Quadrangle Map, or copy thereof, and a copy of the Municipal
Tax Map sheet on which the boundaries of the subject parcel, the Pinelands
management area designation and the municipal zoning designation are
shown.
(g)
A forestry management plan that includes, as appropriate:
[1]
A cover page for the plan containing:
[a] The name, mailing address and telephone number
of the owner of the subject parcel.
[b] The municipality and county in which the subject
parcel is located.
[c] The block and lot designation and street address,
if any, of the subject parcel.
[d] The name and address of the forester who prepared
the plan, if not prepared by the owner of the subject parcel.
[e] The date the plan was prepared, subsequent revision
dates and the period of time the plan is intended to cover.
[2]
A clear and concise statement of the owner's objectives for
undertaking the proposed forestry activities, including a description
of the short-term (five years) and long-term (20 years) objectives
for all proposed silvicultural techniques that will be used to manage
the parcel.
[3]
A description of the existing conditions of the subject parcel
and of each forest stand in which a proposed activity, prescription
or practice will occur. These stand descriptions shall include photographs
of each stand taken at eye level, showing the location of all Pinelands
native forest types, as identified at N.J.A.C. 7:50-6.43, and shall
be keyed to an activity map that shall include, as appropriate, the
following information:
[b] The general condition and quality of each stand.
[c] The overall site quality, relative to the management goals and objectives identified in Subsection
B(2)(g)[2] above.
[d] An inventory and map of Pinelands native forest
types with native forest types broken into "stands," including information
on type, size and volume by species.
[e] The age of representative trees.
[f] The species composition, including overstory, understory,
ground layer structure and composition.
[g] The stand cohort composition.
[j] The structure, including age classes, diameter
at breast height (DBH) classes and crown classes.
[k] The condition and species composition of advanced
regeneration, when applicable.
[l] A stocking table showing the stocking levels, growth
rates and volume.
[m] Projections of intended future stand characteristics
at ten-, twenty-, and forty-year intervals.
[n] A description of the forestry activities, silvicultural
prescriptions, management activities and practices proposed during
the permit period and the acreage proposed for each activity. These
may include but are not necessarily limited to a description of:
[i] Stand improvement practices.
[ii] Site preparation practices.
[iv] Regeneration and reforestation practices.
[v] Improvements, including road construction, stream
crossings, landings, loading areas and skid trails.
[vii] Silvicultural treatment alternatives.
[viii] If planting will occur to accomplish reforestation,
the application shall include seed sources records, if such records
are available.
[ix] Implementation instructions.
[x] Measures that will be taken to prevent the potential
spread of exotic plant species or phragmites into wetlands.
[o] A description, if appropriate, of the forest products
to be harvested, including volume expressed in cords and board feet;
diameter at breast height (DBH) classes and average diameter, age;
heights; and number of trees per acre.
[4]
A map of the entire parcel which includes the following:
[a] The owner's name, address and the date the map
was prepared.
[b] An arrow designating the North direction.
[c] A scale which is not smaller than one inch equals
2,000 feet or larger than one inch equals 400 feet.
[d] The location of all property lines.
[e] A delineation of the physical features such as
roads, streams and structures.
[f] The identification of soil types (a separate map
may be used for this purpose).
[g] A map inset showing the location of the parcel
in relation to the local area.
[h] Clear location of the area and acreage in which
each proposed activity, prescription or practice will occur. If shown
on other than the property map, the map or maps shall note the scale,
which shall not be smaller than one inch equals 2,000 feet or larger
than one inch equals 400 feet, and shall be appropriately keyed to
the property map.
[i] A legend defining the symbols appearing on the
map.
(h)
A letter from the Office of Natural Lands Management identifying any threatened or endangered plants or animals reported on or in the immediate vicinity of the parcel and a detailed description by the applicant of the measures proposed to meet the standards set forth in §§
335-25E and
335-26A.
(i)
A cultural resource survey documenting cultural resources on those portions of the parcel where ground disturbance due to site preparation or road construction will occur and a detailed description of the measures proposed by the applicant to treat those cultural resources in accordance with §
335-33.
(j)
A statement identifying the type, location and frequency of any proposed herbicide treatments and how such treatments will comply with the standards set forth in Subsection
C(9)(b) below.
(k)
A statement identifying the specific steps to be taken to ensure
that trees or areas to be harvested are properly identified so as
to ensure that only those trees intended for harvesting are harvested.
(l)
Written comments from the New Jersey State Forester concerning the extent to which the proposed forestry activities are consistent with the guidelines provided in the New Jersey Forestry and Wetlands Best Management Practices Manual developed by the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, dated October 1995, as amended. Any such comments which indicate that the proposed activities are not consistent with said Manual must be addressed by the applicant in terms of their potential impact on the standards set forth in Subsection
C below.
(m)
A certificate of filing from the Pinelands Commission issued
pursuant to N.J.A.C. 7:50-4.34.
(n)
When prior approval for the forestry activities has been granted by the Zoning Officer or other Township approval agency, a letter from the Pinelands Commission indicating that the prior approval has been reviewed pursuant to §
335-123.
C. Forestry
standards. Forestry operations shall be approved only if the applicant
can demonstrate that the standards set forth below are met:
[Amended 9-22-2011 by Ord. No. 2011-19]
(1) All forestry activities shall serve to maintain Pinelands native
forest types, including those which are locally characteristic, except
in those stands where other forest types exist.
(2) Any newly developed access to lands proposed for harvesting shall
avoid wetland areas except as absolutely necessary to harvest wetlands
species or to otherwise gain access to a harvesting site.
(3) The following actions shall be required to encourage the establishment,
restoration or regeneration of Atlantic white cedar in cedar and hardwood
swamps:
(a)
Clear-cutting cedar and managing slash.
(b)
Controlling competition by other plant species.
(c)
Utilizing fencing and other retardants, where necessary, to
protect cedar from overbrowsing.
(d)
Utilizing existing streams as cutting boundaries, where practical.
(e)
Harvesting during dry periods or when the ground is frozen.
(f)
Utilizing the least-intrusive harvesting techniques, including
the use of winches, corduroy roads and helicopters, where practical.
(4) All forestry activities and practices shall be designed and carried out so as to comply with the standards set forth in §§
335-25E and
335-26A. The species accounts provided in the Recommended Forestry Management Practices Report, Appendix I – Endangered Animals, dated March 2006, as amended and supplemented and available at the principal office of the Commission or at www.nj.gov/pinelands, may be utilized as a guide for meeting these standards.
(5) All forestry activities and practices shall be designed and carried
out so as to comply with the standards for the land application of
waste set forth in N.J.A.C. 7:50-6.79, except as expressly authorized
in this section.
(6) All forestry activities and practices shall be designed and carried out so as to comply with the standards for the protection of historic, archaeological and cultural resources set forth in §
335-33.
(7) A vegetated streamside management zone shall be maintained or established
adjacent to streams, ponds, lakes and marshes, except that no streamside
management zone shall be required when Atlantic white cedar is proposed
to be harvested, established, restored or regenerated. The streamside
management zone shall be at least 25 feet in width. Where soils are
severely erodible, slopes exceed 10% or streamside vegetation is not
vigorous, the streamside management zone shall be increased up to
a maximum of 70 feet to buffer the water body from adjacent forestry
activities.
(8) Stream crossings, access roads, timber harvesting, skid trails, log
decks, portable sawmill sites, site preparation, and reforestation
shall be designed and carried out so as to:
(a)
Minimize changes to surface water and groundwater hydrology.
(b)
Minimize changes to temperature and other existing surface water
quality and conditions.
(c)
Prevent unnecessary soil erosion, siltation and sedimentation.
(d)
Minimize unnecessary disturbances to aquatic and forest habitats.
(9) The following standards shall apply to silvicultural practices for
site preparation, either before or after harvesting:
(a)
In areas with slopes of greater than 10%, an undisturbed buffer
strip of at least 25 feet in width shall be maintained along roads
during site preparation to catch soil particles.
(b)
Herbicide treatments shall be permitted, provided that:
[1]
The proposed treatment is identified in the forestry application submitted to the Commission pursuant to Subsection
B(2)(j) above;
[2]
Control of competitive plant species is clearly necessary;
[3]
Control of competitive plant species by other, nonchemical means
is not practical;
[4]
All chemicals shall be expressly labeled for forestry use and
shall be used and mixed in a manner that is consistent with relevant
state and federal requirements; and
[5]
In pine-shrub oak native forest types, herbicide treatments
shall only be permitted as a method to temporarily suppress shrub-oak
understory in order to facilitate pine regeneration. All such herbicide
treatments shall be applied in a targeted manner so that there will
be no significant reduction in tree or shrub-oak resprouting outside
those areas subject to the herbicide treatment.
(c)
Broadcast scarification mechanical weeding shall be permitted
in all Pinelands native forest types.
(d)
Disking shall be permitted, provided that:
[1]
It shall not be permitted in pine plains native forest types.
[2]
Disking shall only be permitted in pine-shrub oak native forest
types as a method to temporarily suppress shrub-oak understory in
order to facilitate pine regeneration and shall be limited as follows:
[a] Disking may occur one time during the first year
of the establishment of a stand to assure the successful growth of
pine seedlings and may be repeated one time during the second year
of the growth of the stand only in areas where pine seedling establishment
has not successfully occurred; and
[b] Only single-pass disking, which penetrates the
soil no deeper than six inches, shall be permitted.
[3]
It shall not occur in wetlands, except as may be necessary to
establish, restore or regenerate Atlantic white cedar. When so used,
disking shall be limited to shrub-dominated parcels and recently abandoned
agricultural lands.
[4]
It shall follow land contours when slopes are discernible.
(e)
Root raking shall be permitted, provided that:
[1]
It shall not be permitted in pine-shrub oak native forest types
or pine plains native forest types;
[2]
When used to establish, restore or regenerate Atlantic white
cedar, root raking shall be limited to shrub-dominated parcels and
recently abandoned agricultural lands; and
[3]
Root raking debris shall not be piled in wetlands.
(f)
Bedding shall be permitted only in recently abandoned, cultivated
wetlands where there are no established Pinelands native forest types.
(g)
Drum-chopping shall be permitted, provided that:
[1]
It shall not be permitted in pine plains native forest types,
except to create road shoulder fuelbreaks, which shall be limited
to 25 feet in width, or to create scattered early successional habitats
under two acres in size.
[2]
It shall not be permitted in wetlands, except as may be necessary
to establish, restore or regenerate Atlantic white cedar. When so
used, drum-chopping shall be limited to shrub-dominated parcels and
recently abandoned agricultural lands.
[3]
It shall adhere to the following procedures:
[a] No more than two passes shall be permitted, except
to create scattered early successional habitats under two acres in
size;
[b] Drums shall remain unfilled when used during the
dormant season;
[c] Chop up and down the slope on a parcel so the depressions
made by the cleats and chopper blades run parallel to the contour
of the land to help reduce the occurrence of channeled surface erosion;
[d] Chop so the depressions made by the cleats and
chopper blades run parallel to a wetland or water body; and
[e] Avoid short-radium, one-hundred-eighty-degree turns
at the end of each straight pass.
(10)
The following standards shall apply to silvicultural practices
for harvesting:
(a)
Clear-cutting shall be permitted, provided that:
[1]
It shall not be permitted in pine plains native forest types.
[2]
It shall be limited to 300 acres or 5% of a parcel, whichever
is greater, during any permit period.
[3]
A fifty-foot-wide buffer strip, in which only periodic pruning
and thinning may occur, shall be maintained between any clear cut
and the parcel boundaries.
[4]
A buffer strip, in which only periodic pruning and thinning
may occur, shall also be maintained to separate each twenty-five-acre
or larger clear cut from other twenty-five-acre or larger clear cuts,
coppice cuts and seed tree cuts that occur within a fifteen-year period.
The buffer strip separating two twenty-five-acre harvests shall be
50 feet in width and, for a larger harvest, shall increase in width
by one foot for each acre of that harvest above 25, to a maximum of
300 feet in width.
[5]
Where present on a parcel, a minimum of 18 dead snags per acre
of at least 10 inches in diameter at breast height (DBH) and six feet
in height shall be left on the parcel for a minimum of five years.
[6]
The area of the parcel subject to the clear cut shall have contoured
edges, unless the boundary of the clear cut serves as a firebreak,
in which case straight edges may be used.
(b)
Coppicing shall be permitted in all Pinelands native forest
types, provided that:
[1]
It shall be limited to 500 acres in size or 10% of a parcel,
whichever is greater, during any permit period.
[2]
A fifty-foot-wide buffer strip, in which only periodic pruning
and thinning may occur, shall be maintained between any coppice cut
and the parcel boundaries.
[3]
A buffer strip, in which only periodic pruning and thinning
may occur, shall also be maintained to separate each twenty-five-acre
or larger coppice cut from other twenty-five-acre or larger clear
cuts, coppice cuts and seed tree cuts that occur within a fifteen-year
period. The buffer strip separating two twenty-five-acre harvests
shall be 50 feet in width and, for a larger harvest, shall increase
in width by one foot for each acre of that harvest above 25, to a
maximum of 300 feet in width.
[4]
Where present on a parcel, a minimum of 18 dead snags per acre
of at least 10 inches' DBH and six feet in height shall be left on
the parcel for a minimum of five years.
[5]
The area of the parcel subject to the coppice cut shall have
contoured edges, unless the boundary of the coppice cut serves as
a firebreak, in which case straight edges may be used.
(c)
Seed tree cutting shall be permitted in all Pinelands native
forest types, provided that:
[1]
It shall be limited to 500 acres in size or 10% of a parcel,
whichever is greater, during any permit period.
[2]
A fifty-foot-wide buffer strip, in which only periodic pruning
and thinning may occur, shall be maintained between any seed tree
cut and the parcel boundaries.
[3]
A buffer strip, in which only periodic pruning and thinning
may occur, shall also be maintained to separate each twenty-five-acre
or larger seed tree cut from other twenty-five-acre or larger clear
cuts, coppice cuts and seed tree cuts that occur within a fifteen-year
period. The buffer strip separating two twenty-five-acre harvests
shall be 50 feet in width and, for a larger harvest, shall increase
in width by one foot for each acre of that harvest above 25, to a
maximum of 300 feet in width.
[4]
Where present on a parcel, a minimum of 18 dead snags per acre
of at least 10 inches' DBH and six feet in height shall be left on
the parcel for a minimum of five years.
[5]
The area of the parcel subject to the seed tree cut shall have
contoured edges, unless the boundary of the seed tree cut serves as
a firebreak, in which case straight edges may be used.
[6]
Dominant residual seed trees shall be retained at a distribution
of at least seven trees per acre.
[7]
Residual seed trees shall be distributed evenly throughout the
parcel.
(d)
Shelterwood cutting, group selection and individual selection
shall be permitted in all Pinelands native forest types.
(11)
The following standards shall apply to silvicultural practices
for forest regeneration:
(a)
Natural regeneration shall be permitted in all Pinelands native forest types and shall be required in the pine plains native forest type, except as provided in Subsection
C(11)(b) below.
(b)
Artificial regeneration shall be permitted in all Pinelands
native forest types, provided that:
[1]
The use of nonnative cuttings, seedlings or seeds shall not
be permitted.
[2]
The use of hybrid cuttings, seedlings or seeds shall be permitted
if it can be demonstrated that the cutting is from a locally native,
naturally occurring hybrid which will be planted within its natural
range and habitat.
[3]
Cuttings, seedlings or seeds shall be collected and utilized
so as to ensure genetic diversity.
[4]
When used in pine plains native forest types, artificial regeneration
shall only be permitted to restore drastically disturbed sites if
seeds or seedlings from the immediate vicinity have been collected
from local, genetically similar sources.
(12)
Following site preparation and harvesting activities, slash
shall either be retained in piles on the parcel, distributed throughout
the parcel, removed from the parcel, or burned.
(13)
Thinning shall be permitted in all Pinelands native forest types,
including that which serves to maintain an understory of native plants
and/or manage stand composition, density, growth and spatial heterogeneity.
(14)
A copy of the approved municipal forestry permit shall be conspicuously
posted on the parcel which is the site of the forestry activity.
D. Forestry permit procedures.
(1) Applications for forestry permits shall be submitted
to the Zoning Officer and shall be accompanied by an application fee
of $25.
(2) Within 14 days of receipt of an application, the Zoning
Officer shall determine whether the application is complete and, if
necessary, notify the applicant in writing of any additional information
which is necessary to complete the application. Should the Zoning
Officer fail to make such a determination within 14 days, the application
shall be considered to be complete as of the 15th day following its
submission.
(3) Within 45 days of determining an application to be complete pursuant to Subsection
D(2) above, or within such further time as may be consented to by the applicant, the Zoning Officer shall issue a forestry permit if the activities proposed in the application comply with the standards in Subsection
C above or disapprove any application which does not meet the requirements of Subsection
C above. Any such notice of disapproval shall specifically set forth the deficiencies of the application.
(4) Upon receipt of a notice of disapproval pursuant to Subsection
D(3) above, the applicant shall have 30 days in which to correct the deficiencies and submit any necessary revisions to the application to the Zoning Officer for review. The Zoning Officer shall review the revised application to verify conformity with the standards in Subsection
C above and shall, within 14 days of receipt of the revised application, issue a forestry permit or disapprove the application pursuant to Subsection
D(3) above.
(5) Failure of the Zoning Officer to act within the time period prescribed in Subsection
D(3) and
(4) above shall constitute approval of the forestry application as submitted. At the request of the applicant, a certificate as to the failure of the Zoning Officer to act shall be issued by the municipality, and it shall be sufficient in lieu of the written endorsement or other evidence of municipal approval required herein.
(6) In reviewing and issuing permits for forestry applications, the Zoning Officer shall also comply with the Pinelands Area notice and review procedures set forth in §§
335-122 through
335-125.
(7) Forestry permits shall be valid for a period of 10
years. Nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit any
person from securing additional permits, provided that the requirements
of this chapter and the Pinelands Comprehensive Management Plan are
met.
E. Administrative fees. Upon the issuance of a forestry permit pursuant to Subsection
D(3) above, the applicant shall be required to pay of a sum of $250 which shall serve as reimbursement for any administrative costs incurred by the municipality during the ten-year permit period. The applicant shall not be subject to any additional fees or escrow requirements for the duration of the forestry permit.
F. Notification of harvesting. No harvesting shall be
commenced until the applicant has provided the Zoning Officer with
72 hours' written notice of the intention to begin harvesting operations.
All agricultural activities and fish and wildlife
management activities, including the preparation of land and the planting,
nurturing and harvesting of crops, shall be carried out in accordance
with recommended management practices established for the particular
agricultural activity by the New Jersey Department of Agriculture,
the Soil Conservation Service and the New Jersey Agricultural Experimental
Station at Rutgers University.
All development within the Pinelands Area shall
conform to the following requirements:
A. All recreation areas and facilities shall be designed
in accordance with the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection
publication "Administration Guidelines: Barrier-Free Design Standards
for Parks and Recreational Facilities."
B. Improved bicycling facilities shall be provided only
in conjunction with paved roads.
[Amended 3-27-1997 by Ord. No. 97-14]
No hazardous or toxic substances, including
hazardous wastes, shall be stored, transferred, processed, discharged,
disposed or otherwise used in the Pinelands Area. The land application
of waste or waste-derived materials is prohibited in the Pinelands
Area, except as expressly authorized in N.J.A.C. 7:50-6.79. Waste
management facilities shall only be permitted in the Pinelands Area
in accordance with the standards set forth in N.J.A.C. 7:50-6.
All development shall be carried out in a manner
which promotes energy conservation. Such measures may include southern
orientation of buildings, landscaping to permit solar access and the
use of energy-conserving building materials.
No more than one principal use shall be located
on one lot, except for forestry, agricultural, horticulture, fish
and wildlife management and recreational development on agricultural
lands.
[Added 3-27-1997 by Ord. No. 97-14]
A. No structure in the Pinelands Area, including radio
and television transmission and other communication facilities which
are not accessory to an otherwise permitted use, shall exceed a height
of 35 feet.
B. The height limitation in Subsection
A above shall not apply to any of the following structures, provided that such structures are compatible with uses in the immediate vicinity: antennas which do not exceed a height of 200 feet and which are accessory to an otherwise permitted use; silos, barns and other agricultural structures; church spires; cupolas; domes; monuments; water towers; fire observation towers; electric transmission lines and supporting structures; windmills; smokestacks; derricks; conveyors; flagpoles and masts; or aerials, solar energy facilities, chimneys and similar structures to be placed above the roof level and not intended for human occupancy.
C. The height limitation in Subsection
A above shall not apply to the antenna and any supporting structure of a local communication facility of greater than 35 feet, provided that the standards set forth in N.J.A.C. 7:50-5.4(c) are met.