[HISTORY: Adopted by the City Council of the City of Dover 11-13-2013 by Ord. No. 2013.10.09-013 as Ch. 22 of the 2013 Code. Amendments noted where applicable.]
As used in this chapter, the following terms shall have the
following meanings:
Includes all positions appointed by the Mayor and Council
or the City Manager, including appointment to the Housing Authority,
but not employees.
A member of the Dover City Council.
The Mayor, Deputy Mayor and all Councilors and the positions
of ward election officials and Charter Commission members.
Includes all City employees whose salary is paid in whole
or in part from the City treasury and all positions over which the
City Manager, department heads or the City Council has power of appointment.
Any person who is related to an elected or appointed officer
or employee in one of the following ways: spouse, parent, grandparent,
child, grandchild or sibling. The definition also includes all persons
who are members of the same household as the elected or appointed
officer or employee, regardless of whether they are related by blood
or marriage.
No elected or appointive officer or employee of the City shall
take part in a decision concerning the business of this City or engage
in any business or transaction in which he/she or a member of his/her
family, directly or indirectly, has a financial interest, aside from
his/her salary as such officer or employee, greater than any other
citizen or taxpayer, nor shall he/she have any financial or other
private interest, directly or indirectly, which is in conflict with
the proper discharge of his/her official duties.
[Amended 2-27-2019 by Ord. No. 2019.02.13-003]
No elected or appointed officer or employee shall appear on
behalf of private interests before the City board, commission, committee,
subcommittee or authority on which he/she serves. Councilors, however,
may appear without compensation on behalf of constituents or in the
performance of public or civic obligations.
A.
A Councilor or a Councilor with a family member who has a direct
or indirect financial or other private interest in any proposed legislation
or matter of official business before the City Council shall publicly
disclose on the official records of the Council the nature and extent
of such interest. Such disclosures shall be made orally prior to the
legislation or matter being discussed as part of a Council meeting
agenda, or a Councilor may elect to file a written specific conflict-of-interest
disclosure statement with the City Clerk. The statement shall be read
aloud into the record at all public meetings during which the legislation
or matter is discussed. In the case of a nonpublic session, the statement
shall be read aloud at the next public meeting.
B.
A Councilor with a conflict of interest shall recuse himself or herself
from further participation in the matter. "Recusal" means to immediately
remove from discussion and voting. "Recusal" shall also mean the Councilor
is required to physically vacate his or her seat. During a nonpublic
session, the Councilor shall remove himself or herself from the meeting
room.
A.
An appointed officer or employee who, whether paid or unpaid, has
a direct or indirect financial interest or other private interest
in any legislation or matter of official business in the City of Dover
and who participates in discussion before or gives official opinion
to the Council, or otherwise participates in the official business
of the City of Dover, shall publicly disclose on the official record
the nature and extent of such interest. Such disclosures shall be
made orally prior to the legislation being discussed as part of a
Council meeting agenda, or the officer or employee may elect to file
a written specific conflict-of-interest disclosure statement with
the City Clerk. The statement shall be read aloud into the record
at a public meeting. In the case of a nonpublic session, the statement
shall be read aloud at the next public meeting.
B.
Appointed officers and employees with a conflict of interest shall
recuse themselves from further participation in the matter. "Recusal
"means to immediately remove themselves from discussion and voting.
"Recusal" shall also mean the officer or employee is required to physically
vacate his or her seat. During a nonpublic session, the appointed
officer or employee shall remove himself or herself from the meeting
room.
No Councilor or appointed officer or employee shall accept any
gift of $25 or more at one time, or $100 in a calendar year from a
single source, whether in the form of service, loan, thing or promise
or any other form, from any person, firm or corporation interested,
directly or indirectly, in any manner whatsoever in business dealings
with the City. Campaign contributions received during the official
election period shall not be considered gifts.
No Councilor or appointed officer or employee shall intentionally
disclose confidential or privileged information, or other information
learned by virtue of official position as defined in RSA 42:1-a, or
information obtained in sessions pursuant to RSA 91-A:2, I(b) or (c),
concerning the property, government or affairs of the City.
No elected or appointed officer or employee shall invest or
hold any investment, directly or indirectly, in any financial, business,
commercial, or other private transaction which creates a conflict
with his/her official duties.
No elected or appointed officer or employee shall engage in
or accept private employment or render or sell services or goods from
private interests, which such employment or service is incompatible
with the proper discharge of his/her official duties.
No elected or appointed officer or employee shall solicit, negotiate
for or promise to accept employment by any person, firm or corporation
with which he or she is or his or her agency is engaged on behalf
of the City in the transaction of business or which is or may be affected
by his or her official action. In connection with this prohibition,
no elected officer shall assume employment with the City for 365 days
after leaving office.
A.
There is hereby established an Ethics Commission consisting of five Commissioners who shall be Dover residents and appointed by the City Council. At least one Commissioner shall be a former City Councilor or former School Board member as provided in § C11-4 of the Dover City Charter. The purposes of the Ethics Commission are:
(1)
To provide a forum to hear and accept complaints of violations of
ethical standards of behavior for elected and appointed officers under
the jurisdiction of the Ethics Commission.
(2)
To encourage Dover elected and appointive officers and all members
of boards, commissions, committees and subcommittees to act in the
best interests of the City and perform their duties and responsibilities
according to the ethical provisions of the City Charter and City ordinances.
(3)
To require the disclosure of financial interests or other interests
in matters affecting City business where the interests constitute
a conflict of interest.
(4)
To prohibit those holding public office and volunteer positions in
our City from using their positions for personal gain and to foster
the use of such positions only to advance public interests.
(5)
To promote the integrity of City government.
B.
The Commissioners shall serve for three-year staggered terms. The
initial Ethics Commission shall consist of five Commissioners with
one Commissioner appointed for a one-year term, two Commissioners
appointed for two-year terms, and two Commissioners appointed for
three-year terms. Subsequent appointments shall be for three years
unless the Commissioner is appointed to serve out a term to fill a
vacancy. The Appointments Committee shall solicit and screen the applicants.
The Appointments Committee shall present a list of all the applicants
who have applied for a position on the Ethics Commission to the City
Council with the recommendations of the Appointments Committee. The
City Council acting as a committee of the whole shall interview and
select the applicants for appointment to the Ethics Commission either
from the entire list of applicants or based on the recommendations
of the Appointments Committee. The City Council may appoint three
alternate Commissioners for one-year terms. Alternates shall be involved
in the activities and decisions of the Ethics Commission only in the
absence of a regular member or members.
C.
No Commissioner shall be a current City Councilor or School Board
member or other elected official, or a member of any board, commission,
committee or subcommittee of the City of Dover.
D.
The Commissioners of the Ethics Commission shall select a Chair and
Vice Chair on an annual basis. No Commissioner shall serve more than
two consecutive terms as the Chair.
E.
There shall be no compensation for the members of the Ethics Commission.
A.
The Ethics Commission shall operate in an advisory role to the City
Council. The activities of all elected officers and members of all
boards, commissions, committees and subcommittees whose members are
appointed by the City Council shall be within the scope of authority
of the Ethics Commission. The Ethics Commission members shall also
be subject to the jurisdiction of the Ethics Commission. If a member
of the Ethics Commission is the subject of an ethics complaint, the
member shall be replaced in all proceedings by an alternate member.
The Ethics Commission shall not have jurisdiction over the City Manager
or other employees of the City of Dover.
B.
The Ethics Commission shall only receive written complaints signed
under oath before a notary public.
C.
The Ethics Commission shall conduct activities in public, including
the investigation of complaints, presiding over hearings, the taking
of testimony, and deliberations, with the exception of the initial
screening of complaints. The provisions of RSA 91-A shall apply to
the activities of the Ethics Commission.
D.
The Ethics Commission shall apply the provisions of Article X of
the City Charter and this chapter of the Code of the City of Dover.
E.
The Ethics Commission shall provide and require professional training
for the Commissioners. It shall also provide information to the public,
the City Council and members of all boards, commissions and committees
of the City of Dover on the role and functioning of the Ethics Commission
by providing taped reruns of the training sessions as well as other
resources.
F.
The Ethics Commission shall have the power to promulgate its own
rules of order subject to the approval of the City Council. All elected
and appointed officers shall have an ethical duty to fully cooperate
with the activities of the Ethics Commission, including but not limited
to participation in discovery, appearances before the Ethics Commission,
the answering of questions, specific responses to the allegations
and the production of documents in a timely manner at the request
of the Ethics Commission where the request for documents is reasonably
required to investigate and resolve the allegations.
A.
All ethics complaints shall be in writing on a form approved by the
City Attorney, supplied by, and available at, the office of the City
Clerk. All complaints shall be signed under oath before a notary public
provided free of charge by the City Clerk's office and shall be filed
with the City Clerk. Complaints shall only be received from residents
of Dover, property owners in Dover and vendors who engage in business
with the City of Dover. Each complaint shall be confined to a single
subject matter and shall state facts constituting an alleged violation
of the ethics provisions of the City Charter or City Code. The complaint
shall name a specific person or persons who are alleged to have violated
an ethical provision. The complaint shall also state the specific
applicable provision of the City Charter or Code on which the complainant
relies in making the complaint.
B.
All complaints shall only allege facts involving alleged ethical
violations occurring during the 180 calendar days prior to the filing
of the ethics complaint, or the term of the present City Council,
whichever is longer. In addition, all complaints shall require the
complainant to certify under oath the following:
C.
The City Clerk shall seal each ethics complaint and forward the ethics
complaint to the Chair of the Ethics Commission within two business
days of the filing. The Ethics Commission shall meet in nonpublic
session pursuant to RSA 91-A:3, II(c). The Ethics Commission shall
examine the contents of the ethics complaint and conduct an initial
screening of the ethics complaint within 20 business days after the
filing of the ethics complaint with the City Clerk's office. The Ethics
Commission shall take one of the following actions:
(1)
Refer the matter and/or any suspected criminal activity directly
to the Police Department for investigation and possible prosecution
as a criminal matter without further involvement by the Ethics Commission.
There shall be no public disclosure of the complaint by the Ethics
Commission.
(2)
Refer the matter to the City Council for investigation and action
by the City Council as a matter involving the City Manager's actions
or inactions without further involvement by the Ethics Commission.
(3)
Refer the matter to the City Manager for investigation and action
by the City Manager as a matter involving the actions or inactions
of a City employee without further involvement by the Ethics Commission.
(4)
Dismiss the complaint for stating facts that, if true, would not
constitute a violation of the ethical provisions of the City Charter,
City Code or state law.
(5)
Dismiss the complaint for failure to state sufficient facts for establishing
a reasonable basis to believe that an ethical violation may have occurred.
(6)
Dismiss the complaint by stating the reason for the dismissal, in
writing.
(8)
Accept the matter for hearing and decision by the Ethics Commission.
Acceptance of the ethics complaint shall occur upon the determination
by the Ethics Commission that there is a reasonable basis to believe
the facts in the complaint may constitute an ethical violation. The
acceptance of the complaint shall not be construed as a final determination
that an ethical violation has occurred.
D.
The Ethics Commission shall notify the complainant and the person
against whom the allegations were made of the determination of the
initial Screening Committee unless the matter is referred to the Police
Department. The notification shall be made by sending a letter by
certified mail, return receipt requested, or personal service of process.
If accepted by the Ethics Commission, the initial notice shall also
include a hearing date. A copy of the ethics complaint shall be included
with the notice. All complaints, except those referred to the Police
Department, shall be released to the public after the person against
whom the complaint is made has been notified. A copy of all complaints
released to the public shall be available in the Clerk's office.
E.
The Ethics Commission shall conduct a hearing for cases accepted
by the Ethics Commission within 30 calendar days of the date of acceptance
of the ethics complaint by the Ethics Commission. One continuance
of not more than 30 calendar days may be granted, but no further continuances
shall be granted.
F.
Fourteen calendar days' notice shall be provided to the parties for
all hearings. The Ethics Commission may hold prehearing and other
informal conferences prior to the evidentiary hearing to aid in the
disposition of the proceeding. All hearings and informal conferences
shall comply with the provisions of RSA 91-A.
G.
The hearing shall not be subject to the rules of evidence. All evidence
that will reasonably assist the Ethics Commission shall be admissible,
but evidence that is irrelevant or immaterial, unduly repetitious,
insulting, or harassing shall be excluded. The Ethics Commission may
require, with reasonable written notice, the appearance of any official,
board member or employee to appear before it to provide testimony.
H.
The hearing shall provide an opportunity for all parties to be heard
and to present evidence. Witnesses shall testify under oath. Parties
may engage in a brief opening and closing statement. Written memoranda
may be required by the Ethics Commission.
I.
An audio recording shall be made of the proceedings. All recordings
and documents shall be stored with the City Clerk and maintained pursuant
to state law.
J.
The Ethics Commission shall issue a written report within 30 calendar days of the hearing. The report shall include a determination whether the allegations contained in the complaint are actionable or not actionable. In addition, if the complaint is found to be actionable, the report shall include a recommendation on a remedy as provided in § 21-14 for the City Council to consider. The Ethics Commission shall forward a copy of the decision and recommendation with specific findings to the parties and to the City Council. A copy of all reports and recommendations shall be available to the public in the City Clerk's office.
K.
The complainant shall have the burden of proof. The standard of proof
for the Ethics Commission to use for deciding matters before the Ethics
Commission shall be clear and convincing evidence.
L.
Clear and convincing evidence is an intermediate standard of proof
that calls for more proof than that based on more probable than not,
but less proof than that based on beyond a reasonable doubt. "Clear
and convincing evidence" is defined in New Hampshire law as that evidence
that establishes a factual conclusion to be highly probable, rather
than merely more probable than not. It requires that the party having
the burden of proof place in the trier of fact an abiding conviction
that the truths of his/her factual contentions are highly probable.
Otherwise, he/she has failed to prove it and is not entitled to relief.
M.
Upon the establishment of the Ethics Commission, the Ethics Commission
may receive and act on ethical complaints involving allegations occurring
prior to the adoption of this article if the complaint alleges a violation
of an ethical standard in effect on the date of the alleged violation.
Current elected officials affected by ethical standards adopted pursuant
to RSA 31:39-a shall be exempt for a period of 90 days after the adoption
of this article. After the adoption of this article and the selection
of the members of the initial Ethics Commission, no ethics complaint
shall be accepted for filing by the City Clerk's office for 30 days
after the swearing in of the last Commissioner.
A.
All decisions of the Ethics Commission shall be advisory to the City
Council. The City Council is not obligated to accept the decisions
and recommendations of the Ethics Commission.
If any provision of this article is declared invalid or unenforceable
by a court of law, the remaining portions shall remain in full force
and effect.
