The purpose of these sign regulations for the Village of Shortsville
is to allow for adequate identification of the location or occupant
for a parcel of land while protecting public health, safety and general
welfare. All signs and signing systems within the Village of Shortsville
are subject to the regulations that follow in this chapter. These
regulations serve to:
A. Ensure right to free speech as protected under the Constitution;
B. Protect property values, create a more attractive economic
and business climate, and protect the physical appearance of the community;
C. Provide businesses with effective means of identification
while reducing visual clutter through the prevention of excessive
and confusing sign displays;
D. Encourage signs that respect the character and architecture
of the building, site, and district in which they are displayed;
E. Reduce traffic conflicts or hazards by minimizing visual
distractions or obstacles in or visible from the public rights-of-way;
F. Minimize the adverse effect of signs on nearby public and
private property;
G. Avoid personal injury and property damage from unsafe or
confusing signs; and
H. Establish a clear and impartial process for those seeking
to install signs.
The following regulations are applicable to all signs within
the Village of Shortsville unless specifically stated otherwise within
this section:
A. Traffic safety. All signs shall be designed, constructed,
and located in accordance with the following criteria:
(1)
No sign shall be erected at or near any intersection
of any streets, or alleys, or any railway and any street, in such
a manner as to obstruct free and clear vision.
(2)
No sign shall be of a shape or color that may be
confused with any authorized traffic control device.
(3)
No rotating beam, beacon, or flashing illumination
shall be used in connection with any sign display.
B. Design and construction. All signs shall be designed and
constructed in accordance with the following criteria:
(1)
Except for banners, flags, and temporary signs and
window signs conforming in all respects with the requirements of this
chapter, all signs shall be constructed of permanent, weather-resistant,
and durable materials.
(2)
All permanent signs shall be supported by sign structures
that are designed to resist wind pressures, dead loads, and lateral
loads in accordance with the appropriate provisions of Building Code.
All sign supports shall be reviewed as part of the sign design.
(3)
All sign lettering shall be permanently affixed to the sign. Manual changeable copy signs shall be enclosed and locked. Electronic changeable copy signs are subject to the regulations set forth in §
95-52.11.
(4)
Sign color should complement the building and/or
storefront colors. A maximum of three colors, one for the background,
one for lettering, and one for accents and highlights, is recommended.
Subdued, rather than garish or florescent, colors are encouraged.
C. Location. All signs shall be located in accordance with
the following standards:
(1)
Signs shall not be erected within nor project into any public right-of-way, unless otherwise specified within this chapter. Signs must be located on private property with the permission of the property owner and comply with the dimension and setback requirements contained in the Table of Sign Regulations (§
95-52.12).
(2)
The Code Enforcement Officer may without notice effect
removal of any sign illegally placed in any right-of-way within the
Village. The Code Enforcement Officer shall hold said sign for five
days; if the owner fails to claim the sign within this time, said
sign may be disposed of at the discretion of the Code Enforcement
Officer.
(3)
Off-premises signs are prohibited. All permanent
signs shall be located on the site being promoted, identified or advertised.
(4)
No sign shall cover any part of any window unless
specifically permitted under this chapter. No sign shall cover any
door or hinder or prevent free ingress to or free egress from any
door, window, fire escape, or other required exit way.
(5)
Altering or covering of architectural details is
prohibited. No sign shall cover or cause the removal of architectural
details to a building facade including, but not limited to, arches,
sills, moldings, cornices, and transom windows.
(6)
Signs projecting over walkways or sidewalks where
permitted must have a minimum clearance between the bottom of the
sign and the ground of eight feet.
D. Illumination. All signs shall be in accordance with the
following standards:
(1)
Light sources for illuminated signs shall not be
of such brightness as to constitute a hazard to pedestrians or motorists
and shall be shielded so as not to cast an illumination on contiguous
properties more than 0.1 footcandle.
(2)
All light fixtures and wiring shall comply with National
Electric Code. Electrified signs shall bear an approved testing laboratory
label and all electrical connections shall be approved by an approved
inspection agency. All transformers, wires, and similar items shall
be concealed and properly protected from the elements. In the case
of freestanding signs, all wiring shall be placed underground.
(3)
No sign shall contain any actively moving parts. Intermittent illumination, or illumination which involves flashing, blinking, or causes the illusion of movement resulting from the arrangement of lighting, is prohibited, except as regulated for electronic changeable copy signs (§
95-52.11).
E. Maintenance and repair. All signs shall be maintained in
safe and good structural condition, in compliance with all applicable
building and electrical codes, and in conformance with this chapter
at all times. Such maintenance includes replacement of all defective
bulbs, parts, materials, painting, repainting, cleaning, and other
acts required for maintenance of such sign. If any sign does not comply
with the above maintenance and repair standards, the Code Enforcement
Officer shall require its repair and/or removal.
F. Protection of property. Signs shall not be posted in any
manner destructive to public property. Signs shall also not be attached
or otherwise applied to trees, light poles, utility poles, transit
shelters, benches, trash receptacles, news racks, or existing traffic
control signs.
G. Obsolete signs. Any sign that no longer advertises or identifies
the use of the property must be removed within 30 days after written
notification from the Code Enforcement Officer.
H. Failure to comply.
(1)
If any sign is installed, erected, constructed, maintained, or becomes obsolete in violation of any provision of this article, except for nonconforming signs in compliance with §
95-52.10, the Code Enforcement Officer shall notify the owner or user thereof to comply with the provisions of this article by certified mail.
(2)
If the owner or user fails to comply with such notice
within 10 days, and the owner has not requested an opinion as to the
existence of the violation from the Board of Zoning Appeals, the Code
Enforcement Officer shall cause the sign or such portion thereof that
is in violation of this article to be taken down.
(3)
The owner or user of the sign and/or the owner of
the property on which the sign is located shall be responsible for
any expenses incurred by the Village in the removal process. The Village
Board shall ascertain the cost of such removal, and such cost shall
be charged and assessed against the owner, tenant or occupant of the
property. The expense so assessed shall constitute a lien and charge
on the real property on which it is levied until paid or otherwise
satisfied or discharged and shall be collected in the same manner
and at the same time as other Village charges.
The following types of signs may be erected in the Village without
obtaining a permit from the Code Enforcement Officer. Although permits
are not required for these signs, the signs shall conform to the height,
setback, and size requirements detailed in this chapter:
A. Banners or pennants. Such signs shall not require a permit
only if all the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)
There shall be no more than one banner per enterprise
at one time;
(2)
It shall be displayed for no more than 30 days;
(3)
It shall not have a total face area in excess of
100 square feet nor a height of more than four feet;
(4)
It shall not extend above the first-floor facade
of the building or project beyond property lines;
(5)
It shall not be illuminated; and
(6)
It must not be placed in such a manner as to impede
pedestrian traffic.
B. Construction or home improvement signs. No permit shall
be required for temporary construction or home improvement signs should
the following conditions be met:
(1)
A maximum of one sign is installed and located within
the limits of the construction site;
(2)
The sign area does not exceed six square feet in
residential districts, or 12 square feet in all other districts; and
(3)
The sign shall be displayed for no more than 30 days.
C. Decorations. Temporary displays of patriotic, religious,
charitable, or civic character with no commercial message, including
holiday lights and decorations that are erected for customary periods
of time.
D. Directional signs. Signs that provide direction and are
located entirely on the property to which they pertain and do not
advertise a business and do not exceed four square feet in area. Directional
signs include signs identifying public rest rooms, public telephones,
walkways or signs providing direction, such as parking lot entrance
and exit signs, and those of a similar nature. Such directional signs
shall be allowed within the street setbacks and side and rear yards
in so far as they do not obstruct free and clear vision to traffic.
E. Drive-through signs. Businesses with drive-through facilities
may have one sign not exceeding 24 square feet for each drive-through
lane provided such signs are oriented solely for the use of patrons
utilizing the drive-through lane and are not intended to be visible
from adjacent property or the right-of-way. If the drive-through lane
or facility is removed or not operating for a period exceeding 60
days, the sign must be removed.
F. Flags. The flags, emblems or insignia of any nation, political
subdivision, including those of commercial and noncommercial interest.
Flagpoles shall be subject to the height restrictions imposed by each
respective zoning district. Commercial flags shall be limited to one
per lot.
G. Gasoline station price signs. Signs not exceeding three
square feet advertising the price of gasoline and indicating self-service
or full-service, when attached to a gasoline pump or pump service
island.
H. Governmental signs. Any official sign, public notice, or
warning sign supported by federal, state or local law, including but
not limited to signs erected and maintained pursuant to and in discharge
of any government functions. (Example: New York State inspection station
or authorized repair shop identification). There are no size requirements
for governmental signs.
I. Historical signs. Signs that are in the nature of cornerstones,
commemorative tablets, and historical signs, provided that such signs
are less than nine square feet and not illuminated.
J. Home occupation signs. One sign for each legally established
home occupation, not to exceed three square feet in area.
K. House numbers and nameplates. Address and/or name of occupant
of premises for a residential structure, not including designations
as to employment or home occupation, are to be limited in size to
three square feet per dwelling unit.
L. Incidental signs. Such signs shall have an aggregate area
not to exceed three square feet at each entrance and shall be attached
to a permanent structure.
M. Internal signs. Any sign within a building not legible
from the right-of-way or adjacent lots, or any sign within an enclosed
outdoor space, such as athletic field, where sign is not legible beyond
the property lines.
N. Limited signs. Signs and notices advertising an open house,
sale, or event displayed for no more than 30 days. These signs must
be placed on the property where the open house, sale, or event is
being held.
O. Noncommercial signs. Any lot shall be allowed up to two signs of any type containing solely noncommercial messages provided said signs are in conformance with the size, height, setback, and illumination regulations set forth within the Table of Sign Regulations (§
95-52.12; Table 52-1) for each applicable sign type.
P. Political and campaign signs. Political and campaign signs
on behalf of candidates for public office or measures on election
ballots are permitted without permit under the following conditions:
(1)
Up to two signs of any type per lot in conformance with the size, height, setback, and illumination regulations set forth within the Table of Sign Regulations (§
95-52.12; Table 52-1) for each applicable sign type;
(2)
Said signs are not placed more than 30 days in advance
of said election or ballot; and
(3)
Said signs are removed upon closing of the applicable
election or ballot.
Q. Portable signs. One nonilluminated, two-sided portable
sign not to exceed 16 square feet in size and five feet in height
in the following situations:
(1)
New businesses awaiting the erection of a permanent
sign, not to exceed a period of 30 days.
(2)
A business that has lost the use of an existing sign
by reason of fire or other catastrophe, not to exceed a period of
30 days.
(3)
All portable signs must be placed at least 10 feet
from all property lines.
R. Real estate signs. Up to two signs on any lot or parcel, provided that such sign is located entirely within the property to which the sign applies is in conformance with the size, height, setback, and illumination regulations set forth within the Table of Sign Regulations (§
95-52.12; Table 52-1) for each applicable sign type.
S. Sandwich board signs or "A-frame" signs. One sandwich board
sign is permitted for each business. Said sign cannot exceed six square
feet in area. Said sign must be removed at the close of each business
day. Said sign must comply with all applicable provisions this chapter.
A sandwich board sign shall not require a sign permit if the following
conditions are met.
(1)
Sign cannot be more than three feet in height and
three feet in width.
(2)
Sign shall not be illuminated.
(3)
Sign shall be displayed only during business hours.
(4)
Businesses located within the Village Center Zoning
District, which under normal circumstances would be prohibited from
erecting a sandwich board due to the lack of ownership of sufficient
frontage, may place a sandwich-board sign within the public right-of-way
during business hours. Said sign shall be erected in such a place
and in such a fashion as to make it as unobtrusive as possible for
pedestrian traffic. The Village shall retain the right to request
movement of the sign if it determines that the sign was not erected
in such a fashion and that a different placement would provide less
obstruction to pedestrian traffic.
T. Temporary signs for noncommercial events or programming. Temporary signs in accordance with §
95-52.9 of this article shall be permitted for use by noncommercial groups or organizations for the promotion of their events or programming. This may include, but is not limited to, religious institution events, nonprofit fundraisers, etc.
U. Works of art. Works of art that do not include a commercial
message, logo, or trademark and do not contain any property identification
message.
The Table of Sign Regulations, located in §
95-52.12, lists the requirements for different types of permitted signs that might be proposed for installation in the Village. The Table addresses each type of sign by zoning category, listing whether each sign type is permitted in each zone, the number of signs permitted per site, and the allowable size, height, setbacks, and lighting regulations.
The following types of signs are prohibited:
A. Signs for which a permit is required, but no permit was
issued or the permit was revoked;
B. Obsolete signs or signs that are not properly maintained,
considered structurally unsound, hazardous or otherwise unsafe;
C. Signs that contain words or pictures of an obscene or pornographic
nature;
D. Signs that emit audible sounds, odor, or visible matter;
E. Signs that may be confused with a traffic control sign,
signal or device or the light of an emergency or road equipment vehicle;
or bear one of more of the words "stop," "go slow," "caution," "danger,"
"warning" or other similar words; or hide from view any traffic or
street sign, signal or device;
F. Signs that interfere with official traffic lights or traffic
control devices;
G. Flashing, rotating, revolving signs/lights;
H. Signs with unshielded lighting devices or reflectors placed
to outline or provide the background of a sign;
I. Cabinet signs, or any such sign that is internally illuminated;
J. Animated signs or signs utilizing full motion or video
technology;
L. Permanent banner, pennant, windblown or inflated signs.
These may be permitted as a temporary sign for a total of 30 days;
M. Portable signs attached to or placed on an unregistered
vehicle parked on private property for the primary purpose of being
viewed by motorists within the right-of-way;
N. Pennants not affixed to the face of a building;
O. Signs placed on a curb, sidewalk, hydrant, utility pole,
trees or other objects located on or over any street or within the
public right-of-way unless otherwise permitted;
P. Signs, banners, or pennants mounted on or extending above
the roof of any building or structure;
Q. Signs painted directly on an exterior wall; and
R. Freestanding signs supported by a single or multiple poles
or posts with more than 30 inches clearance from the bottom of the
sign to the ground below, commonly referred to as pole signs.
See the "Table of Sign Regulations" in §
95-52.12 for sign allowances.
A. Residential districts.
(1)
Signs advertising use for public, quasipublic, nonprofit,
religious institution, educational institutions, hospital or other
similar uses, shall be located on the same premises as the use.
(2)
One freestanding sign not exceeding 16 square feet
in area and five feet in height is allowable by permit at the entrance
of a subdivision or residential development provided it is not internally
illuminated and has a minimum setback from the public right-of-way
of 10 feet. The sign may be installed after approval of the Planning
Board of the final subdivision plat or when a valid building permit
has been issued. If a building permit is not issued or construction
does not begin within 12 months of Planning Board approval, said sign
must be removed.
(3)
All other uses are allowed two signs by permit in accordance with §
95-52.12, Table of Sign Regulations.
(4)
The use of electronic changeable copy for a sign
or any part thereof in residential districts is strictly prohibited.
B. Nonresidential districts.
(1)
Two signs per use are permitted for a single business
or industry. Where contiguous businesses or industries are located
on a single lot, such as, but not limited to, industrial centers,
or business parks, each business or industry shall be permitted two
signs and a single freestanding sign may be permitted for the lot.
(2)
Where groups of two or more contiguous stores are
located together, one sign per use shall be permitted in addition
to one freestanding sign for the mall or plaza.
(3)
Signs within the Village Center District shall be
permitted at the rate of two per use.
(4)
Window and door signs shall not be included in the total sign count for a building or use, provided they meet the standards listed in §
95-52.12.
Temporary signs shall be permitted without a sign permit provided
they are in conformance with all other applicable regulations of this
article, including:
A. Term. A temporary sign may be placed upon a property or
structure for no more than 30 days in any ninety-day period.
B. Number. Only one temporary sign is permitted per lot or
structure at any given time.
C. Illumination. Interior illumination of temporary signs is prohibited. Signs requiring exterior illumination or electricity shall conform to the regulations of §
95-52.3D of this chapter, and those within the Table of Sign Regulations (§
95-52.12; Table 52-1).
D. Size, height, clearance, and setback requirements. Temporary sign area, height, and setback requirements shall follow the same regulations set forth for any permanent sign of similar type or configuration within the applicable zoning district. See Table of Sign Regulations (§
95-52.12; Table 52-1).
All signs permitted by the Village shall be subject to the regulations
set forth in Table 52-1 below, where "P" indicates permitted and "NP"
indicates not permitted.
Table 52-1 Table of Sign Regulations
|
---|
|
R-1
|
NC
|
VC
|
I
|
---|
Zoning District
|
Village Residential
|
Neighborhood Commercial
|
Village Center
|
Industrial
|
---|
|
|
|
|
|
Freestanding Signs (Monument)
|
Any sign not affixed to a building constructed at grade level
with continuous foundation.
|
---|
R-1
|
NC
|
VC
|
I
|
---|
Permitted in Zone
|
NP
|
P
|
NP
|
P
|
Maximum number permitted
|
—
|
1 per lot
|
—
|
1 per lot
|
Maximum area (square feet)
|
—
|
6
|
—
|
50
|
Maximum height (feet)
|
—
|
5
|
—
|
6
|
Setback (feet)
|
—
|
10
|
—
|
10
|
Internal lighting
|
—
|
NP
|
—
|
P
|
External lighting
|
—
|
P
|
—
|
P
|
Wall Signs
|
Any sign fastened to a building or structure in such a manner
that the wall becomes the supporting structure for or forms the background
surface of the sign. The sign will not project more than 18 inches
from the building or structure.
|
---|
R-1
|
NC
|
VC
|
I
|
---|
Permitted in Zone
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
Maximum number permitted
|
1 per structure
|
1 per structure
|
1 per use
|
1 per use
|
Size allocation NOTE: *whichever is less
|
2 square feet
|
20% or 12 square feet*
|
20% or 2 square feet per linear foot of frontage*
|
100 square feet
|
Maximum height (feet)
|
—
|
—
|
4
|
—
|
Internal lighting
|
NP
|
NP
|
P
|
P
|
External lighting
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
Projecting Signs
|
A sign wholly or partly dependent upon a building for support
and which projects more than 18 inches from the building.
|
---|
R-1
|
NC
|
VC
|
I
|
---|
Permitted in Zone
|
NP
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
Maximum number permitted
|
—
|
1 per structure
|
1 per use
|
1 per use
|
Maximum area (square feet)
|
—
|
6
|
20
|
20
|
Vertical clearance (feet)
|
—
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Internal lighting
|
—
|
NP
|
NP
|
P
|
External lighting
|
—
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
Maximum projection (feet)
|
—
|
4
|
4
|
4
|
Suspended Signs
|
A sign attached to and supported by the underside of a horizontal
plane.
|
---|
R-1
|
NC
|
VC
|
I
|
---|
Permitted in Zone
|
NP
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
Maximum number permitted
|
—
|
1 per structure
|
1 per use
|
1 per use
|
Maximum area (square feet)
|
—
|
3.5
|
3.5
|
3.5
|
Vertical clearance (feet)
|
—
|
8
|
8
|
8
|
Internal lighting
|
—
|
NP
|
NP
|
P
|
External lighting
|
—
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
Awning and Canopy Signs
|
Any sign that is a part of or attached to an awning, canopy,
or other fabric, plastic, or structural protective cover over a door,
entrance, window, or outdoor service area.
|
---|
R-1
|
NC
|
VC
|
I
|
---|
Permitted in Zone
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
Maximum number permitted
|
1 per structure
|
1 per structure
|
1 per structure
|
1 per structure
|
Internal lighting
|
NP
|
NP
|
NP
|
NP
|
External lighting
|
NP
|
NP
|
NP
|
NP
|
NOTE: Awning signs may only be placed in the area encompassed
by the bottommost six inches of the awning edge that runs parallel
to the ground.
|
Window and Door Signs
|
A non-electric sign applied or attached to the interior of a
window or door or within three feet of the interior which can be seen
from the exterior.
|
---|
R-1
|
NC
|
VC
|
I
|
---|
Permitted in Zone
|
NP
|
P
|
P
|
P
|
Maximum number permitted
|
—
|
—
|
—
|
—
|
Size allocation (maximum % of window area)
|
—
|
20%
|
20%
|
20%
|
Internal lighting
|
—
|
—
|
—
|
—
|
External lighting
|
—
|
—
|
—
|
—
|
Electronic Changeable Copy Signs
|
Any sign, or portion thereof, on which characters, letters,
or illustrations are changed mechanically or electronically in the
field without altering the face or surface of the sign, including
without limitation, an electronic or mechanical message center.
|
---|
R-1
|
NC
|
VC
|
I
|
---|
Permitted in Zone
|
NP
|
NP
|
NP
|
P
|
Maximum number permitted
|
—
|
—
|
—
|
1 per lot
|
Size and setback requirements
|
See freestanding sign requirements.
|
Temporary Signs
|
Any sign that is used only for a short, specifically limited
time and that is not permanently mounted.
|
---|
R-1
|
NC
|
VC
|
I
|
---|
Permit requirement guidelines for specific sign types shall
also be applied as defined above.
|
Maximum number permitted
|
1 per lot
|
1 per lot
|
1 per lot
|
1 per lot
|
Internal lighting
|
NP
|
NP
|
NP
|
NP
|
External lighting
|
See applicable sign type above.
|